Trudeau is Right: Canada is a Post-National State

Just tell me what you think of the video senpai.

Daily reminder, Canadian taxpayers paid for THIS:

youtube.com/watch?v=Wb55teb1gJ0

F

Attached: BEIGE POWER.jpg (640x357, 88K)

It's true but not in a Jewish sense because Canada is as same as USA it was only established as an Artificial Colony.
Christianity is not a culture it's a Religion, and so does playing Hockey and eating maple syrup.

It has no cultural dresses and dances of it's own.

Also food, myths/tales, folk songs. And it's very own language. Every country has it's own around the world.

Do you think the USA is a postnational state as well?

Yes but the two North American countries can always forge their own culture. You just need to last long enough for people to start creating a culture of it's own.

wtf does this guy think the difference is between a country and a nation?

Watched the video
>There's nothing unique aboot canadian identity

Anything and everything that undermines Canada will be supported by cancer like Trudeau

Attached: 1568897989057.png (802x881, 1.22M)

Trudeau is so based

An economic zone is a place where there is no culture and people come to work like a sugar plantation or a gold mine in the past or silicon valley today. A nation is a country inhabited by unique people with a unique, culture, history, and identity. He used Japan as an example. Japan has a distinct culture with clothes, music, religion, myths and aesthetic unique to it.

Canada is more like a modern version of a sugar plantation.

Yet your faggot ass government still don't accept as many migrants as the US. Fucking hypocrites.

can anyone redpill me on the NDPs and Green

Canadians are so cute and chummy, I want to pinch their cheeks and hug them tight.

Attached: 123.jpg (619x495, 22K)

Nice try jew

Fucking Canada. If you bastards were anywhere else in the world you would have been conquered and genocided by now. But no, you get to park by us and not have to spend any money on defense so you can splurge on pure and utter faggotry. Bastards.

Alright ill watch ur video user
>im probably going to piss off people
just say your opinion faggot

>canadian history is boring
maybe read a book and you will learn something

>Canada was basically an economic zone
It was first French, then the French lost the war to the British so it is therefore British North America. As a Colony of Britain our main purpose was to send natural resources back to Britain. However, Canada is particular in north america because they resisted republicanism in the south and stayed loyal to the British crown. Even the Quebecers had a positive opinion of the British crown. This is what makes us different.
>Theres nothing unique about Canada
look up

>We're influenced by America, Britain, and France.
Yeah no shit idiot. Thats why we have the cbc and crown corporations to resist American influence and stay British. Quebec being French is a thing that is a byproduct of basically the British engaging in a faustian bargain to permit Quebec as a nation as long as they fight with them against the Americans.
Again, READ HISTORY

>mounties are just Canadian because they wear red and ride horses
wow you are a dumb nigger, read history, the mounties were created to kick americans out when they trespassed and tried to sell bootleg liquor to Canadian native tribes. When you think of American Cowboys putting the law in their own hands the mounties were not that far off but the difference is that mounties believed in law, order.

Stop being a meanie!

>im seeing increasing larping about mounties and Queen Elizabeth
equivocating reactionary thought which believes in a sovereign king/queen = larping apparantly.
Honestly stop talking like such a faggot holy shit. Thats not an argument at all, the british monarchy is part of our history. Just because communists want to get rid of it doesn't make it "larping" now

Don’t you dare insult Nazism by implying that it is, in any way, anything to do with Canada.

>muh rock band, poutine
holy shit you are retarded these things are not a national identity.

>isolated population
its almost like communists are trying to import niggers and poos so that people thing we're not a nation

NUPC was a Canadian national socialist party

Attached: first-convention-of-the-nupc-1-july-1938.jpg (1348x871, 455K)

21 minutes of cucking. No thanks.

>most nationalist people dont talk about Canada
Who the fuck are you talking about? Faith Goldstien and Lauren Simonsen? Lmfao you have no idea kid

>21 minute video
>channel named after yogurt brand
Dairy-loving CGDF detected, fuck off with your advertising

Fuck white people

>nationalism is just cringe yeh its so just soooo cringey
>im just cringing right now can u tell im cringing

DUDE STFU

Canada was very involved in setting up the charades known as WWI and WWII.

Canada certainly has a culture. Your opinion betrays your ignorance and the mask slips. Why don’t you ask the immigrants you claim to love so much what they think of our culture? You can’t see it because you’re immersed in it.

>they get no support
>therefore they are wrong
holy shit you are a brainlet, do you even know what a logical argument is?
Maybe they dont get support because faggots like you are more interested in playing vidya and watching animes then giving a shit about the future of your nation. Ever thought about that OP

Canada consists of the 13 colonies that were neutered and too polite to rebel, and everyone knows it.

Prince Justi! Handsome is he, Justi Canada
That physique! How can I speak, weak at the knee

Attached: 4L_s4SjXs2c.jpg (780x439, 66K)

Read these books you faggot

Attached: 1520220919016m.jpg (760x669, 150K)

>canadian history is boring
>maybe read a book and you will learn something
Canadian history is boring because nobody lived here. We had a very small population that was isolated so literally nothing happened.

>Canada was basically an economic zone
>As a Colony of Britain our main purpose was to send natural resources back to Britain.
>and stayed loyal to the British crown.
This is exactly what an economic zone is. Canada was a logging and resource extraction site where people would send workers. A logging camp isn't a nation, silicon valley isn't a nation.

>We're influenced by America
This means that were an offshoot of America which is itself just an economic zone.

>the mounties were created to kick americans out when they trespassed and tried to sell bootleg liquor to Canadian native tribes.

That is literally what the British East India Company did to protect its resource extraction sites. This is just corporate interests protecting their economic zone.

>NDP
Has fallen a long way from being the official opposition to Harper, I don’t think Jagmeet knows what he’s doing really. He promised not to vote with the conservatives if his party holds the balance of power.
>Greens
Elizabeth May got drunk and cried over Omar Khadr’s $10mil at some event, doubt she could effectively negotiate internationally. She promised to vote with the Liberals if her party holds the balance of power as well.

>Canada is a post national state right now
yeah right now
>It always has been
No you are a fucking brainlet if you think that. If you read any Canadian history you would know that Canadians were rooted in reactionary, anti-republicanism, and traditionalism.
Canada was French for a while, then it was taken by the British into British North America (at that point the U.S was still British NA) then when the U.S rebelled against the British Canada stayed loyal.
Also read this book if you have doubt Canada was a nation.

Attached: nation.jpg (295x450, 29K)

>he thinks America has no culture too
I didn’t think I’d ever see the day a leaf is more ignorant than an American

>Canadian history is boring because nobody lived here. We had a very small population that was isolated so literally nothing happened.
Its pretty obvious you've never touched a history book in your life.

>This is exactly what an economic zone is. Canada was a logging and resource extraction site where people would send workers. A logging camp isn't a nation, silicon valley isn't a nation.
I didn't say it stayed a colony forever. If you read Nation Maker you will read how our first prime minister created a National Policy to create trade within Canada. Making us no longer just a colony or as you put it "economic zone"
We built a railroad from one end to the other in the first years of this country for that exact reason.
listen to this: youtube.com/watch?v=Yzo6Otpgj-E

>This means that were an offshoot of America which is itself just an economic zone.
influence =/= offshoot
Also every real politician worth a damn in Canada fought american influence with every bit of their body. Its loser faggots like you who dont give a damn that is why this country is falling.
youtube.com/watch?v=pNbFLlMIp28
GOODBYE JIM AND JACKIE
HATE TO SEE YA LEAVIN
BUT IF YOU DONT BELIEVE YOUR COUNTRY
SHOULD COME BEFORE YOURSELF
YOU CAN BETTER SERVE YOUR COUNTRY
BY LIVING SOMEWHERE ELSE

>That is literally what the British East India Company did to protect its resource extraction sites. This is just corporate interests protecting their economic zone.
lol im laffin bud, the mounties were there to kick out americans becuase the liquor was destroying the natives. John A created them for this reason and again if you read any history book u would know this.

Attached: John_A_Macdonald_election_poster_1891.jpg (270x416, 29K)

I'm going to fucking cum in my pants the day someone finally puts a bullet in that faggot's head.

What was the difference between Canada and a British East Indian sugar cane farm?

If you're going to mention rules and culture. Silicon Valley has it's own rules and culture meant to prevent the workers from fighting each other. Political correctness is how you prevent conflict in a multi-racial economic zone.

America is a giant wal-mart.

>What was the difference between Canada and a British East Indian sugar cane farm?
The land and the people. They were both British colonies for a time and they have that in common but different colonies will develop in different ways depending on the people and the land they're working on.
Canada as a Nation is rooted in Britishness but those roots are what allows us to grow into our own.

Every Canadian learns our fucking history nigger. It's part of the curriculum.

>If you read Nation Maker you will read how our first prime minister created a National Policy to create trade within Canada.
Economic zones export within their own country. Your likey using software that was developed in a corporate economic zone.

There is virtually no difference between Canada and America, except we're more liberal and don't have guns.

>lol im laffin bud, the mounties were there to kick out americans becuase the liquor was destroying the natives.

The british east india company would employ soldiers sometimes local fighters to create stability in their resource extraction colonies. Today gold mines have security and regulation on drinking and drug consumption.

Have you ever watched The Number 23? Have you ever heard of confirmation bias? Challenge your own opinions, stop trying to impose them on the world. You’re tilting at windmills.

>Every Canadian learns our fucking history nigger. It's part of the curriculum.
They dont teach you shit and most people forget about high school stuff in 1 - 2 years. It is not a substitute for learning on your own and reading.

>Economic zones export within their own country. Your likey using software that was developed in a corporate economic zone.

There is virtually no difference between Canada and America, except we're more liberal and don't have guns.

Just because an economic zone exists does not make it not a nation. The national policy is to create more trade within Canada than trade outside Canada because if you trade with an outside force they will influence your culture. This is why the CBC exists, and we have a history of crown corporations.

>The british east india company would employ soldiers sometimes local fighters to create stability in their resource extraction colonies. Today gold mines have security and regulation on drinking and drug consumption

They are resisting AMERICANS. They are fighting an external fight. This helps create a national identity of anti-americanism.

>Have you ever heard of confirmation bias? Challenge your own opinions, stop trying to impose them on the world.

Projection. Saying Canada is an economic zone or position is not a mainstream opinion. Even Trudeau shocked people when he said that. Look at the facts, look at what canada is and where it came from.

DUDE LET'S JUST GIVE UP OUR NATIONAL IDENTITY AND BECOME SLAVES TO MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS LMAO

In the video you explain that Poland is a nation state because they had been left to themselves for a long time.
A National Policy, ie a policy to CREATE a nation was to make it so that Canada would be able to be left to themselves to build a nation.
A Nation isn't created out of thin air, it has to be built by people who are willing to sacrifice a bit of themselves for a larger cause.
Because liberals and communists are against this they spew republicanism and now young Canadians like yourself think theres no such thing as a Canadian.

>Just because an economic zone exists does not make it not a nation.
It doesn't make it a nation either. You have to prove Canada is a nation.

>They are resisting AMERICANS. They are fighting an external fight. This helps create a national identity of anti-americanism.

Fur traders would resist INDIANS this creates a culture of anti-indianism.

Trudeau is also a drama teacher. He probably has about as much knowledge of Canadian history as you do lmao.
His father Pierre Elliot Trudeau was a literal communist and enacted policies to open up Canada to foreigners and foreign influence.
You are being played by Bolsheviks.
pic related is pierre elliot trudeau and justin trudeau in the red square in soviet russia

Attached: pet_red_square.jpg (1200x711, 362K)

Canada is a multinational corporation that's his point.

Then he should dissolve the central government and step down

Attached: 1569111086567.png (363x324, 251K)

Saying Canada is a cultureless resource extraction site is challenging my own opinions. Nobody is taught to think this.

>fur traders would resist indians
The first fur traders WERE the indians you dumb fuck. Holy shit hahaha.

Listen, I know its hard because theres so much communist broadcasting that tells you
>you have no history
>you have no nation
>you have no common identity

Canada was being BUILT into a nation. I would say for about a hundred years we were one and then the soviets started pouring propaganda and we then had Multiculturalism policy and a Charter of human rights and all that bullshit.
Reminder we didn't have that for a hundred fucking years. These policies were made by communist traitors whose sole intention was to destroy Canada as a nation.

I’m not wasting my time watching your video, and I hardly care what Justin says. He’s a rich kid who barely grew up, who thinks he’s above our culture.

Canada never achieved its quest to build a nation. It's just been a continuous resource extraction site from its founding.

>agreeing with the prime minister is challenging my preconceived notions
Sub-100 IQ detected

He hates you
He hates his job
He hates his life
He always hated you
They always hate you

Attached: 1556902918233.jpg (701x1024, 89K)

bud you live in southern ontario and said in the video your fav part of Canada is parts of Toronto.
Maybe try and get out of the city and see the rest of Canada and its people before you go around saying we have no culture.
Maybe go to the Legion and tell that to the people who've lived here for generations, with families who've died in wars for this country, and tell them "ya the only reason those people fought and died was for resource extraction" you wont do that though because by now you realize that that would be fucking retarded

Attached: cbpepe2.png (484x416, 105K)

>The first fur traders WERE the indians you dumb fuck.

There were wars between fur traders and indians. Some of the early fur traders were Indians sure but this was soon overtaken by the French. Indians would raid white settlements for valuable goods like furs.

>I would say for about a hundred years we were one

No, we weren't. Many English colonies used to extract resources had a trace of british culture because they created the extraction sites, but that's like saying a cotton farm is its own nation because brits work there.

I love driving to and through small towns, seeing all the community efforts. It’s really beautiful.

We aren't taught that from birth. We're taught Canada is a unique great country in opposition to America. That's why his comment caused outrage.

>Canada never achieved its quest to build a nation.
I'd say it did rather quickly. We were basically an autarky for close to 100 years. Everything that was built in Canada, was built by Canadians.
Canada as a nation was distinctly British and rejected republicanism of the south.
This is EXACTLY the reason we should never have gotten rid of the old flag and should have hung the politicians who changed it.

The Red Ensign shows a Nation, distinctly British with the Union Jack but represents the people of Quebec, and the Irish.
The Red represents socialism, which Canada required to resist American republicanism.
Canada's political tradition is Red Toryism, or in todays terms a socialist conservative.

Attached: 250px-Canadian_Red_Ensign_(1921–1957).svg.png (250x125, 8K)

>(((post-national state)))

Attached: 9463827640.jpg (308x842, 112K)

Resource extraction sites have small towns, how else are we going to extract the fish?

That’s just what normies say because they want to feel (ignorantly) superior to Americans. Trudeau has been traipsing around the world wrecking our country’s image and you’ve fallen for it.

>There were wars between fur traders and indians. Some of the early fur traders were Indians sure but this was soon overtaken by the French. Indians would raid white settlements for valuable goods like furs.
This was before Canada was even a thing. Did you know Native tribes fought on either side of the British and French war. Thats not something they teach kids anymore because they just want to demonize the nation that we created.

>No, we weren't. Many English colonies used to extract resources had a trace of british culture because they created the extraction sites, but that's like saying a cotton farm is its own nation because brits work there.
British culture is the largest influence for Canada's culture. We were a British nation. When you come to Canada you swear allegiance to the Queen.
Thats not a bad thing, thats who we are and its only recently that they are trying to scrub this out.

>This is EXACTLY the reason we should never have gotten rid of the old flag and should have hung the politicians who changed it.
It’s too late. It’s long past due to rip the rest of the bandaid off and divorce ourselves from the UK and the monarchy.

Listen dude resource extraction sites have their own laws and flags. What makes a nation a nation is a unique people, culture and heritage.

You could make the case that Quebec is a nation because the Quebecois are a unique people and their culture is different from France, but anglo Canada is just America-lite which is just a giant shopping mall.

A place where people come to take oil out of the ground, and shop isn't a nation.

>Resource extraction sites have small towns
muh resource extraction
muh resource extraction
kid stfu, everywhere on earth people will extract resources to use for their lives.
The point is that Canada extracts it themselves, without american or british influence and we did it for a hundred years and that was helping to create a national identity of customs and traditions.

>Comments are disabled for this video.

of course!

>Canada certainly has a culture.
No, it had a culture several decades ago.

The second we do that faggots like OP will clamour over want to be American. I was born a Canadian and I will die a Canadian.
We face the exact same battle that our fathers of confederation faced.
For too long we've let american liberals and communists tell us we have no identity.

...

>Destroy Canada with immigration and forcefully remove any sense of culture from the country
>"Canada has no culture so therefore we shouldn't have borders or be against immigration!"

Attached: 1550447870165.jpg (480x480, 21K)

No, you’re a defeatist

>This was before Canada was even a thing.
Indian raids on colonial settlements were routine in Canada's founding. Yes, I know natives fought on both sides.

American culture is the largest influence.

I like the one of him getting punched in the face. Instead of a glove it should be with brass knuckles

>unique people, culture and heritage.
which we were creating through a national policy

>becois are a unique people and their culture is different from France,
this is a very recent phenomena, free trade with america is less than decades old. The only reason we have giant shopping malls is because of traitor politicians putting money before the nation.

>A place where people come to take oil out of the ground, and shop isn't a nation.
No its not but thats not what Canada was. Americans are literally laughing at us for taking all our oil when we could be using it as a nation to fulfill our needs first.
Dont you realize whose side your on? Your more american than Canadian so why dont you just get it over with and move there for good.

We use Indian and Chinese workers in our economic zone. If a place is built around having multiple groups working to collectively raise GDP with nothing in common and no unifying culture beyond consumption then it's an economic zone.

They'll say Tim Hortons and maple syrup is great.

I don’t disagree all that much brother. It’s nice to see the mask slip from OP, to see that Ontarians see the west as nothing more than “resource extraction areas”. What a joke.

Daily reminder: CBC is about to be defunded.

>Indian raids on colonial settlements were routine in Canada's founding.
no they weren't lmfao.

Chief Crowfoot of the Blackfoot: "The police (rcmp) have protected us as the feathers of the bird protect it from the frosts of winter"
The natives were dying because the buffalo had run out and the government was sending them food rations.
The RCMP arrested more white man in the first 50 years of its founding than natives, even though they primarily operated on native land.

>American culture is the largest influence.
But it was never supposed to be and Canada national purpose might as well be described as "resist americanism". Yes they influence us but to a large degree we fought against it.
Again, its only recently that they have been succesful in telling Canadians we have no culture and "may as well be american" and if you genuinely believe that then MOVE THE FUCK SOUTH FAGGOT

>The only reason we have giant shopping malls is because of traitor politicians putting money before the nation.
This is why they promote immigration too. Huge companies need workers and the citizen birthrate is falling. Instead of addressing the issue of birthrate they just import more workers.

Sure. Left vs. Farther Left

Jesus dude read Canadian history. When we let a few Chinese workers people rallied to put a head tax on them. For almost a hundred years up to ww2 theres was a policy of "None is Too Many" as immigration. Canadians wanted to build Canada with Canadian labour. Communist lliberals and americans want to see us mixed up with other peoples so that our national identity is destroyed.

Yep. they dont put their nation first so the nation is crumbling. Then OP will cope and say "we've always been just an economic zone" lmfao

Our identity before becoming Americas hat was a British economic zone like the ones in the west indies.

Attached: Canadians South Park.png (720x405, 163K)

Yeah thats why we put tariffs on British goods in the first decades of our country.
go to a fucking library