I don't know, A kinda got a reason, give it to her why not

James Gonzalez
James Gonzalez

I don't know, A kinda got a reason, give it to her why not.

Attached: b.jpg (152 KB, 960x720)

Elijah Cook
Elijah Cook

I would give it to C just to trigger Bfags

also nice original thread

Kayden Carter
Kayden Carter

Child B because she made it and thus it belongs to her
This doesn't have much or any significance to my political leanings, though

Attached: Gakkou-Gurashi-2.gif (920 KB, 500x281)

Henry Gray
Henry Gray

Children don't talk like that lol

Jayden Brown
Jayden Brown

Fuck all 3 i'm keeping it

Hudson Taylor
Hudson Taylor

FUCK
MARRY
KILL

FUCK THIS THREAD OP

David Gonzalez
David Gonzalez

Give it to C because I hate women

Evan Lewis
Evan Lewis

B because she fucking made it

Hudson Watson
Hudson Watson

None of the above. I have no right to take it from child B in the first place so I wouldn't be giving it to anyone.

Jayden Brooks
Jayden Brooks

only rational person in this thread

Xavier Walker
Xavier Walker

It literally BELONGS to child B

Aiden Diaz
Aiden Diaz

B should sell it to A while C bitches for UBI

Juan Brooks
Juan Brooks

Why did they start fighting over a flute is the real question? If child B made it how did it end up in the position that everyone wanted it? Does that situation justify the other people's positions or diminish them?

Mason Edwards
Mason Edwards

I don't understand how child B isn't the only obvious answer

Eli Sanchez
Eli Sanchez

lol of course the man is the only one with the most shitty situation.

Attached: 1483135368381.gif (896 KB, 500x377)

Henry Phillips
Henry Phillips

C is the only male child
I choose C

Brayden Peterson
Brayden Peterson

Have you ever considered people think differently?

Ryder Foster
Ryder Foster

let them all fight to the death

Alexander Hughes
Alexander Hughes

some people are stupid
correct

Brody Cooper
Brody Cooper

It's not a man, just a lesbian.

Josiah Price
Josiah Price

Child B is the answer because it's an obviously gross oversimplification of a complex problem.

Michael Fisher
Michael Fisher

found the /pol/ster

Gabriel Robinson
Gabriel Robinson

Becuase in this setting you're apparently a commie fuck who already stole it from child B and are trying to decide who to redistribute it to. They are only fighting becuase you made it belonging to child A or C rather than it's rightful owner an option by stealing it from her in the first place.

Angel Thomas
Angel Thomas

I like your solution the best, I think

Blake Baker
Blake Baker

Child A gets the flute. Anyone saying Child B isn't looking at the bigger picture. Child B shouldn't be making flutes if she doesn't intend to sell them or use them.

Ethan Davis
Ethan Davis

B is the owner of the flute, so it's her choice what to do with it. You're stealing it from her if you give it to A or C.

Zachary Reyes
Zachary Reyes

Came here to say thisHow the fuck can you just take something from someone who made it? Seriously how can you claim any kind of moral high ground when you advocate thievery?

Caleb Walker
Caleb Walker

Fucking americans, how is this even a question

Jack Russell
Jack Russell

If Child B made the flute then they are the owner. I don't have any right to give it to someone else because it isn't mine.

Easton Cooper
Easton Cooper

Child B, she made it, can do whatever she sees fit with it.

Luke Reed
Luke Reed

What if she wants to masturbate with it?

Joseph Lewis
Joseph Lewis

Go for it, I'd hope I can watch or receive a filming of it. Either way it's hers, so go crazy.

Lincoln Reed
Lincoln Reed

Keep it for myself because kids need to learn about how the world works

Ian Cruz
Ian Cruz

Child A, so that she can play the flute and drum up demand for flute sales for Child B

Jaxson Martinez
Jaxson Martinez

Child C because it is our moral imperative to redistribute property

Alexander Turner
Alexander Turner

anyone who chooses anything but b

Attached: pinochet3.jpg (60 KB, 640x640)

James Hughes
James Hughes

Snap it in half and watch them cry

Jackson Thompson
Jackson Thompson

dissemble the flute and make smaller flutes and sell it at an increase price.

Mason James
Mason James

C my comrades...

Christopher Garcia
Christopher Garcia

Child B cause we aren't commies

Camden Perry
Camden Perry

The flute was made to be played. That was the very purpose of its existence in the first place. If the flute is not used to produce music, than its existence will be illogical. The matters of who produced the tool, who earned it, who deserves it: all of those are vanities, they matter not. The materials, resources and time applied in the making of the tool is irrelevant. All that matters is its function, its purpose on this universe, its proper use. Therefore, the flute must go to the one who can properly utilize it. Any other choice is literally human subjectivity and is ultimately irrelevant when you analyze the fact: a flute exists. Therefore, it must be played.
With that I conclude that I would give the flute to A so we all could enjoy the music.

Carter Ramirez
Carter Ramirez

Americans parroting stale anti communist propaganda
Colour me surprised

Cameron Perry
Cameron Perry

I agree. A will provide the most return.

Isaac Cook
Isaac Cook

I cannot give that which was never mine to begin with. The whole contrivance is bankrupt from the start. Let Child B negotiate the value of her potentially beautiful but dead work, and Child C bargain for an opportunity to learn a Skill. If Child A cannot make a compelling case for her own skill as a flute player to Child B, let her earn it with her strength. If they can't or won't learn to negotiate among themselves, then they'll have to learn the truth of the very poverty they put themselves in by not finding a way to use their resource wisely.

Filthy Statists

Carter Ross
Carter Ross

Kill A and C for attempting to violate the NAP.

Attached: 1477133624993.png (66 KB, 547x402)

Jaxon Lopez
Jaxon Lopez

And if it is an art piece? Y'know meant for decorative purposes.

James Lopez
James Lopez

Came here to post this, you are a gentleman and a scholar

William Rivera
William Rivera

Lol k, I'm gonna jump in and say A, because of Aristotle.

Aristotle suggested the idea of tell, which is an innate property, a "purpose", of sorts, for a given thing. Everything has a telos, a chair, a stream, a human, and in this case, a flute.

How do you determine telos? Simple, you pose a telologic question and the answer defines the telos. In this case, you might ask, "what is the purpose of a flute?" or phrased differently, "a good flute _____" and then you fill in the blank.

In this case, a good flute is one that produces good music, a good flute is played *well*.

To maximize the tells, we should give the flute to child A.

Attached: g7QG7JP1-YhXuejICeF--ydL-Sity1rQ9JIdJGxV6Xw.jpg (32 KB, 672x559)

Austin Torres
Austin Torres

Fuck it have a serious answer.

I'm gonna jump in and say A, because of Aristotle.

Aristotle suggested the idea of Telos, which is an innate property, a "purpose", of sorts, for a given thing. Everything has a telos, a chair, a stream, a human, and in this case, a flute.

How do you determine telos? Simple, you pose a telologic question and the answer defines the telos. In this case, you might ask, "what is the purpose of a flute?" or phrased differently, "a good flute _____" and then you fill in the blank.

In this case, a good flute is one that produces good music, a good flute is played *well*.

To maximize the telos, we should give the flute to child A.

Attached: kustIhKOmLfPfA92z4kLhewb3H-4YTTg3KIPpo3u8Ek.jpg (94 KB, 720x960)

Brayden Morales
Brayden Morales

The flute was made to be played
No, it was made because the maker made it. It doesnt matter if the flute doesnt get played

Brandon Cox
Brandon Cox

Marxist theory of personal property suggested Child B should keep the flute.

Bentley White
Bentley White

Well, can you agree that there are flutes that could be considered better, or at least, more flute-like, than other flutes?

We make these internal judgements all the time. We choose to use pens that aren't square shaped or made of razor blades because they wouldn't be good pens.

Attached: g7QG7JP1-YhXuejICeF--ydL-Sity1rQ9JIdJGxV6Xw.jpg (32 KB, 672x559)

Henry Foster
Henry Foster

Id keep it. Laters losers

Attached: 153580b8.png (110 KB, 349x371)

Kevin Roberts
Kevin Roberts

Yes, but I dont see how that is relevant. The flute has no purpose it needs to fulfill. It is just a product. A potter doesnt NEED to fill her pots with something if the creation of the pots was the end goal. It would be wrong for a person to steal the potters' pots for the purpose of filling them with things

William Harris
William Harris

What anime is this iooooiiioiiorgi?

Eli Sanchez
Eli Sanchez

POLICE (original muted)

Cameron Long
Cameron Long

A is an arrogant cunt
C has no significant reason to recieve the flute

William Brooks
William Brooks

Go back to North Korea.

Jace Morris
Jace Morris

Yes it does, leftists would give it to C or A

Jace Richardson
Jace Richardson

This shouldn't make me laugh so hard but it does

Carter Smith
Carter Smith

only people from /pol/ are against communism
fucking kek

Isaiah Peterson
Isaiah Peterson

Calm down, B

Ryder Bailey
Ryder Bailey

A is fascism/national socialism
B is capitalism
C is communism

Jack Miller
Jack Miller

Under fascism/national socialism, B would get some form of compensation for making the flute for A though.

Joshua Brooks
Joshua Brooks

Under Capitalism, D, who owns the Kindergarten, would be entitled to 90% of the flutes value.

Grayson White
Grayson White

You were right when you said the pot doesn't need purpose and wrong when you mentioned thievery
It's the same thing; once something is, it can be protected or destroyed. Neither is the preferred because preference is from within you. On an outside scope, there is none. Should the universe implode, it would do nothing to protect itself and why should it? Because we live? No

Jaxson Watson
Jaxson Watson

Whats A then? I have no clue and have been trying to figure it out for ages

Bentley Moore
Bentley Moore

Utilitarianism
(seriously fucking original)

Andrew Rogers
Andrew Rogers

I think fascim or national socialism are as close as you can get, but nobody would really choose A without caveat as it would make B stop producing high quality flutes.

Cooper Powell
Cooper Powell

Sounds like the reason for planned obsolescence and why America no longer makes the reliable, durable products it was once known for
Democracy is a mask

Josiah Hernandez
Josiah Hernandez

Which political ideology does this tie into the most?

Lincoln Ward
Lincoln Ward

People only say the other ones as poorly constructed b8 or as a joke.

Andrew Carter
Andrew Carter

How the fuck is a flute made by a blue-haired 6 year old going to improve Cs life immeasurably? Is it immeasurable because its 0?

Attached: 98f64371c6cca793f4e1815de5fa20d5.png (300 KB, 451x447)

Elijah Torres
Elijah Torres

If you choose B you are a socialist.

Attached: slide-6.jpg (160 KB, 960x720)

Leo Murphy
Leo Murphy

It's b's if she wants a to have it a can buy it.
Welcome to capitalism marxcucks

Attached: 1522964909043.jpg (49 KB, 700x455)

Ayden Butler
Ayden Butler

a

original commnt

Blake Baker
Blake Baker

Ahh, propaganda for capitalistic ideals.

Lincoln Torres
Lincoln Torres

How is A proficient with the instrument if they do not already have access to one? So, basically, A is scamming everyone to get another flute so they can fuck right off for being a Jew. B is smart enough to make flutes, and C is clearly a layabout, so they could probably come to some sort of factory line agreement between them to make more flutes, of which C gets one in payment.

Attached: 1524503401356.png (953 KB, 1029x994)

Andrew King
Andrew King

How about this

A, to maximize its productivity. BUT I compensate B with it. Make it a regular thing, so B manufactures flutes for talents like A for compensation. BUT A has to agree that she will play the flute regularly, competetively, and compensate 30 percent of the profit to me, who got her the flute

Mason Ward
Mason Ward

I think you're overthinking things, whoever makes the thing has the choice of where it goes. Therefore B can do what it likes with it.

Ryan Phillips
Ryan Phillips

I'm liberal and would give it to B. Fuck off with your "hurr durr leftist boogeyman would choose the wrong option" attitude, dumb underage /pol/tard.

Owen Anderson
Owen Anderson

fuck A
marry B
kill C

ez

B is productive
C is useless
A is talented

John Williams
John Williams

I mean, under a normal life circumstance its B but this is clearly about economic ideals regarding private property, wealth distribution and welfare. No way in hell a single flute would have a significant effect on the life of C

Easton Diaz
Easton Diaz

all the fucking brainlets in this thread
say you're going to cut it into 3 pieces and give one to each
the child that protests the most ends up getting it

Anthony Clark
Anthony Clark

Child C deserves to starve and should never attain a flute . worthless ginger

Nicholas Allen
Nicholas Allen

B made it, so it gets it.
A is the second choice.
C can go fuck itself.

Isaac Miller
Isaac Miller

I want your phone because you're not using it to phone any friends therefore I should have it

Attached: 1527199110681.jpg (463 KB, 600x450)

Liam Allen
Liam Allen

orginaIIy Delet this

Blake Smith
Blake Smith

...Is this from the bible?

Kevin Morgan
Kevin Morgan

Break the flute into thirds.

Aaron Thompson
Aaron Thompson

The flute belongs to whoever owns it. It doesn't matter who produces it, who needs it, or who can make the most of it. Only the owner of something owns it.