--> Quick Questions Quick Replies Why would I want a NAS/Homeserver? If you ask why then you don't need it.
>I want a NAS/HTPC/Plex what should I get? RPi3 or Odroid XU4/HC1. Odroid upper models has USB 3 and USB bus separated from the Ethernet one.
>B-But muh ARM Then check the onboard x86 like J4105B-ITX, J4205B-ITX or J4205-ITX. All of them have SATA and USB 3.
>What's the best [software] for doing [ask]? Specify you question and elaborate. If you want help put something from your side.
>Which disk is better for my homeserver? Seems like Green WD are not sold nowadays. So WD Reds are okay for the price if you want "NAS Drvies". Otherwise HGST and Toshiba are your friends.
What RAIDZ2 setup should I get, Jow Forums? I have 20 TiB of data and want at least 30 TiB of space in my new servers so it lasts 5-10 years.
I know 6 drives is ideal for not wasting space in RAIDZ2 but buying 6x10TB disks and only ending up with ~30 TiB of usable space (when you include overheads, 15-20% free space requirement etc.) seems pointless. Should I go 8x10 TiB instead and use 1 MiB block sizes to avoid wasted padding space? Most of my files are huge Blu-ray rips (30-100 GiB).
I could also keep my current 3x 5 TiB disks as a backup array in RAIDZ1 but I don't have space in my case for more than 10 disks. So maybe I should go 8x 10 TiB RAIDZ2 + 2x 5 TiB mirror?
Jaxson Powell
FreeNAS. Got me 14TB of space with ~100MB/s transfer.
Matthew White
Why would I want a NAS/Homeserver?
Joseph Phillips
- To store porn in one place, access from many workstations. - To make remote user profiles. - To follow 3-2-1 backup policy. - To run some other services (torrent, plex, dns, dhcp, etc.)
Aiden Morales
you using that ssd as l2arc cache?
Parker Jenkins
You, personally, don't.
Next question?
Charles Harris
I would go with the 10tb's myself if you are running out of space, Maybe even think about 12tb ones, they aren't that much more and lots of models to choose from. not sure setting the block size to 1mb will really do anything for you though.
Brandon Collins
Personal cloud. I've got a server running and I grabbed a used lightweight thinkpad, and now I basically VPN in as a thin client to access my crap. I need to think of a solution to allowing HTTP traffic outside of the VPN since that's not needed all the time, and interferes with file I/O inside the network.
Jason Phillips
1 MiB block size would only help with reducing wasted space in an 8-disk RAIDZ2 setup.
I did think of 12 TiB disks but the price premium is high compared to 10 TiB (in the UK at least). Just dunno whether to get 6 or 8.
Gabriel Green
aah, equality at it's finest.
Jonathan James
I'm quite new on this. I was sure I should use SLOG (which is for ZIL). Also, I don't have for now link aggregation so 125MB/s would be theoretical max.
Wyatt Morales
How are you working out that the 1mb block sizes are better, doesn't ZFS compress the data anyway?
Noah Brooks
What's the best extremely lightweight alternative of OwnCloud you can run on OpenWRT? I would like to setup a storage for outside people so I don't have to let them inside my full OwnCloud installation. I've thought about FTP but that requires people to setup 3rd party software. Any ideas?
Anyone here run/tried running a home server with the OS running purely off a USB flash drive? Also is it true Moot used to run Jow Forums that way? What would be a good OS to try this with? Debian?
Nolan Cooper
>Anyone here run/tried running a home server with the OS running purely off a USB flash drive? Yes, I'm doing that on a Fedora box in a WOL on-off operation that takes backups.
Linux doesn't care, it's all a block device to it.
> What would be a good OS to try this with? Debian? Virtually any Linux, even though I assume some might have a crappy installer that filters for SATA or IDE drives and makes picking a USB drive tricky you could still just install to a VM and then put that appropriately on an USB. Or hack the installer or such.
Others will let you pick the USB or paths where the USB partitions will be mounted with the option to not format them, then it's easy.
Parker Harris
Yes but it doesn't attempt to compress incompressible data, which the vast majority would be (videos).
most servers and OS's already run off USB drives, SDcards or satadoms. Most OS's will just read the data on boot and have minimal writing back to the drive.
I think wangblows even supports it now but has a higher write endurance capacity requirement as it still writes a bit of data back to the DOM so wears it out
Why? I have my OS on an SSD and also 2 VMs that run off that SSD. Can't really do that with a USB flash drive.
An M.2 one would avoid using a SATA port too.
Dominic Smith
What's a good torrent client for Linux with a good web interface that won't choke with a few torrents?
Juan Peterson
rtorrent is quite popular for seedboxes
Luis Long
Fuck that image depresses me. Could be me one day :(
Will code for food.
Charles Bailey
t. burger
Christopher Powell
Why what? Why use flash as a boot drive?
So you don't need to waste a port for it. that ssd could be another storage drive, that m.2 ssd could be a cache. That's why
You may not have a need for it for your 5 drive array, but in most SMB/enterprises, rackspace, performance and ports are at a premium.
Noah White
breh, you use NVMe for boot drive because you want a snappy OS. a flash drive for OS is fucking retarded for anything other than a portable linux boot.
Gavin Turner
breh, this isn't /pcbg/, you're in a home 'SERVER' general.
90% of servers boot from flash. that's why they have internal USB ports/SD card readers/independent sata ports. Nobody's saying you should run your gaymes and wangblows 10 on a usb drive.
Lucas Jones
this is 'HOME server general', nigger. your made up statistics dont mean shit.
Matthew Bennett
>a flash drive for OS is fucking retarded for anything other than a portable linux boot. No, young inexperienced one. It's actually no problem to run Linux off a random cheapo USB stick.
You don't even have to make sure it's a good one. It'll work okay either way.
Carson Powell
i said if you want a snappy OS, you obviously dont if you're ok running off a thumb drive
John Cox
And I said it's no problem.
Yes, your server is going to start up, start programs and read configs and all that in a snappy fashion.
Don't bring your Wangblows experience into hosting things on Linux, it doesn't transfer.
Joseph Torres
Isn't this that girl that had beef with Vice?
Elijah Sullivan
Jeez, chill you dudes. I'm the user who asked about running Linux on flash, I asked because I'm trying to set it up on a broken-screen laptop ""server"" which I plan to use to develop on. It currently has a 30GB 1.8" HDD which cost much more than a typical 2.5" would have when I bought it and if it craps out at some point I want to try switching to flash only. I only need about 32GB or even 16GB. Debian doesn't take more than 1GB for a base install, the rest would be to store a database etc.
Brayden Clark
For reasons I can't explain, my router and my server are in two separate locations, and running a wire would be a pain in trying to make the job look "clean". What's the best route here? Mesh or powerline?
Landon Myers
can anyone think of a way to stream background/system PC audio to an iOS device over 3G/4G? I have a program that has audio alerts that I would like to get on my phone when I'm AFK. I have it figured out through Soundwire and an android tracfone I have lying around that works but would prefer to carry only one phone.
Aaron Wilson
reminder that the hsg discord is shit and its just mentally ill traps larping as sysadmin
While the typical OS and stuff is no real problem, a much used database may actually be one of the somewhat problematic things to put on USB. Even more so if it's using an also otherwise busy USB2 controller.
But you can simply try it.
Whichever works better. Powerline actually can be worse or better than WLAN depending on the situation.
Since it's cheaper to try, probably just get a 300-1600Mbit WLAN hardware and if necessary, a repeater [anything from a $7 Xiaomi stick to a powerful AP acting as repeater]..
Protip: Still keep a cable ready near the server, you might hit the situation where it not looking clean is less important than full speed GBE data access. You can use a flat cable to make it a bit smaller and more likely to fit through closed doors, at least wood-framed ones.
Aaron Bell
I haven't actually played with modern MacOS or Win10 yet. You can finally just dial in the FTP credentials into the file manager and it lets you browse it? Or you still need a FileZilla? The idea was that I could provide my customers with just an IP-name-password and they would be able to send me big files without me having to give them access to the main server...
Jayden Brooks
Where do I find passive SATA expanders, everything touts itself as having state of the art drivers, data protection capabilities and whatever else the fuck they want to hype up. I just want more ports, and I want my server to have direct access to the drives instead of a man in the middle board.
Carson Howard
But it's also the discord that keeps these threads alive..
> You can finally just dial in the FTP credentials into the file manager and it lets you browse it? Explorer has been able to do this for ages.
Apple products frequently surprise me with what kind of standard shit they can't do, but FTP is maybe not one of these. I don't know.
> The idea was that I could provide my customers with just an IP-name-password and they would be able to send me big files without me having to give them access to the main server... Give out an email address and make / rent a http site where they can upload files [ideally prevent overwrites and postfix or prefix UNIX timestamp to file names]. That's the thing customers would expect most.
But FTP should also work, I guess.
Nathan Lopez
use transmission like every other decent human being
Adrian Brooks
>passive SATA expanders You mean port multipliers for controllers that hopefully support FIS? Aliexpress.
If you don't have FIS or don't know, buy [more/bigger] PCI controller cards instead.
Might also be done on Ali, the 2-4 port controllers in particular are dirt cheap.
Austin Flores
I just use it so I can access certain things on all my computers, but only store them in one place + for backups (which obviously means you need at least 2 disks).
Alexander Morales
>DLNA is there a somewhat simple DLNA solution where I don't have to be on the same network, such as with soundwire where I open a port and point the app to my IP? I saw icecast/shoutcast in my search but couldnt be arsed to look through the docs but I guess if it can't be helped
Angel Reyes
>is there a somewhat simple DLNA solution where I don't have to be on the same network You can do all of the above over the internet, just make the respective ports and services internet accessible the usual way [for your network - in most cases that means port forwarding on your router].
Or you can virtually hook yourself into your home LAN over wireguard or VPN. It's easy to secure this method quite well and then it works for just about everything, so it's quite appealing.
Although I guess the easiest option is to pay plex or emby for a subscription - I think most of the service you pay for is actually that you get devices linked by account in various ways.
Ryder Martin
what can you do with a homeserver besides NAS? I had enough spare parts from old builds to make a decent second computer not sure what I should really do with it but I had some old hard drives to put in it
Tyler Howard
Can I run a webserver and email server on a raspberry pi 3? What about security? Do I need a cluster of 4 PIs to have enough power for that?
Levi Kelly
Even a single rpi1 would be enough let alone a rpi3, let alone a cluster of 4
Michael Jones
>what can you do with a homeserver besides NAS? Everything computers can do.
Host your own email server. Encode data from surveillance cameras. Search through your petabytes of anime or porn images [/ derived perceptual hashes and what not] for the waifu picture you just handed it. Control a flock of quadcopters. Control home automation. Host video game servers. Be part of a 3D render farm. Compile packages for your fork of CloverOS. Run git and continuous integration for software you develop. Host your own *booru. Host your own enterprise management system / logistics inventory system. Donate processing power to BOINC / GIMPS...
Jason Martin
I currently got a raspberry pi 2 b and this shit got no power
Xavier Wood
You need just one. Although I'd prefer an ODroid XU4Q or something in case you find another use for it like as a media / backup / ... server, too.
Security is going to be the normal Linux / BSD distro's security; unless you mess it up it's surely okay enough.
Nicholas Edwards
I ended up using VLC and streaming via http to the VLC app on my phone as this does exactly what I need it to do but looking into the DLNA angle helped me find this, thanks.
Jaxson Taylor
Great that you found a solution. No problem.
Tyler Myers
if the server is available via internet with portforwarding are there really no risks associated?
Does the pi need to be in it's own network, so my home network is safe?
Elijah Powell
Why is rtorrent prefered over transmission?
Juan Long
it isnt
Kevin Taylor
Both ESXi (vsphere) and Server 2016 nano run from flash.
Why on earth would you dedicate spindles / flash storage to your hypervisor?
Carter Lopez
This guy(op pic) is a ADMIN mod on Jow Forums
Chase Ward
Yeah it is. Your data is only as safe as you make it. Everything critical is ran from a UPS, even the ISP Modem/Router and 8 port Switch
James Davis
Can you imagine the horror of re-ripping/re-downloading all 3.9TB of media for example if a drive or server just went tits up unexpectedly?. To say nothing of the rest of the data. The time it'd take to do it V.S restoring from backup.
Then here's the really scary bit: If this was on a regular NTFS Raid volume, well, after so many years silent data errors creep in. So your backups are worthless. That once pristine video rip of Thor (2011) is now contaminated with "video errors" that show up on playback. Just makes you sick don't it?
Kevin Nguyen
>i dont understand how backup works >i dont understand how bit rot works stay retarded
>Apple products frequently surprise me with what kind of standard shit they can't do, but FTP is maybe not one of these stay retarded, pic related
No, i'm what keeps these threads alive
you're a retard too
rackspace and ports arent at a premium you tard, even at a colo rackspace will be cheapest part of your bill.
that ethot clicking next a lot has nothing to do with servers
>if the server is available via internet with portforwarding are there really no risks associated? You can configure what is accessible from where, use encrypted connections and passwords, and many more things.
Also, just don't forward the things that don't need to be forwarded?
> Does the pi need to be in it's own network, so my home network is safe? Not really, no? I'm going to guess you have far less secure Windows / Android / IOS / ... machines connected to the port forwarded home network anyhow.
Jackson Nguyen
>stay retarded, pic related Yea, that's what I said. A lot of standard shit doesn't work on Apple's expensive trash software, but FTP maybe is not one of the standard things that aren't supported.
Jeremiah Howard
what version of freenas is this?
Caleb Myers
Define premium
Do you want to needlessly buy a 2u over a 1u? throwing money away for no good reason.
The point stands, using a drive for boot media is retarded for 90% of use cases. Stop being awkward for the sake of being awkward, faggot.
Shit loads of huge companies boot from flash drives are you retarded?
Aaron Wilson
>fun pc builidng simulator game >but still no fun network simulator game I would unirronically buy 3D version of packet tracer for 20 bucks desu
Brayden Gomez
When the fuck did I say that? I meant wasting a 2.5/3.5" drive bays Curb your autism, fucking hell.
Matthew Hughes
>why would anyone want power loss protection on a SSD And if you're going to go full autismo with a SD card/USB memory key, you might as well just netboot it with PXE or iSCSI
Carson Moore
I really really like this image
Caleb Garcia
>AM1 5350, 8Gb RAM >running Ubuntu server >kimchi for virtual machines >Plex for TV and media >Openvpn >Nginx for web pages >Git
id rather have those agps just stop circlejerking (literally) in the discord and let the threads thrive here theres nothing good about that place seriously
Josiah Hughes
Then why are you here?
David Taylor
because i wanna discuss homeserver stuff and read about homeserver stuff and not read about users buying their newest pair of panties and how they sucked some guy off last weekend like they can go to a lgbt discord for that but they post in a tech related discord and its always linked back here, makes the generals look bad
Brandon Taylor
these generals are bad. There is a handful of people with servers and the rest are just retards who think their shitbox with less power than a phone is a server.
Hudson Butler
yeah true but being associated with sissy fucks doesnt help them either going too off topic though