Hey Jow Forums, what sort of classical music do you listen to?
I know Wagner is traditionally the choice, but I'm hoping you guys have some recs for good classical music besides him.
As far as my tastes go, my favorite composers are Tchaikovsky and Rachmaninoff, but I'm also a fan of Schubert's Winterriese and traditional choral music. I dislike impressionist composers like Debussy.
What are some good nationalist works that aren't entry level that I can put on while I read Evola tonight?
The standards, of course, Beethoven, Mozart. I'd also recommend Dmitri Shostakovich (you'll love his 2nd waltz), Chopin, Rossini, Offenbach, Georges Bizet, Edvard Grieg, Johann Strauss. For choral music look up Pachelbel, some different Bach pieces, old byzantine chants, not very big into that.
Chopin is the best to me. Piano only gets my juices flowing.
Robert Hughes
Thanks m8. I'm playing Shostakovich right now, and you're right, the waltz is right up my alley. I think it might be because I really like ballets, has a similar feel to me.
Vaughan Williams is one of my favorites. I love what he did with old English Chorales. Also, his Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis really speaks to me on a spiritual level.
>being so retarded you think political thinking and issues are necessarily linear kill yourself OP. >inb4 libtard >inb4 muh unironically believing an understanding of hierarchy is important while simultaneously ignoring it when it comes to some arbitrary system of progression
Jackson Morales
Antonin Dvorak Alexander Scriabin
Nicholas Perez
Vivaldi is my favorite, but everybody likes different composers for different reasons. Check this out m.youtube.com/watch?v=SY3Kxf7ZTeI
Ryder Clark
It is interesting to see how pol appreciates Rachmaninoff when he usually gets overlooked.
>he usually gets overlooked Is this a joke? If anything he's even more overplayed than the other Russian Romantics.
Bentley Reyes
Go for Shostakovich and Pfitzner if you want to be edgy. The symphonies of Furtwangler, expecially the 2nd, are fine as well.
Isaiah Ortiz
>Scriabin My negro.
Eli Morales
Holst, nigga. The Planets is classic.
Camden Nelson
This is exactly the type of bullshit that makes people hate classical. Listen to what you like, fuck everyone else.
Btw, putting Tchaikovsky up there is a disservice, his waltzes were some of the best.
Levi Morales
I don't know much about classical music but I like listening to Bruckner.
Ian Taylor
If you're willing to go back as far as the 1600s, Claudio Monteverdi is a great composer right on the border between the Renaissance and Baroque periods. In particular I really enjoy his opera L'Orfeo youtube.com/watch?v=0mD16EVxNOM
He's consistently placed low in rankings compared to inferior composers.
Xavier Clark
Might as well listen to Hans Zimmer soundtracks. There is literally nothing wrong with having standards.
Connor Martin
>He's consistently placed low in rankings Low is where he belongs.
Caleb Johnson
Ayyy my mans. Got a little Gotterdammerung on rn. Saturn to come.
Isaiah Cook
Classical elitism is the death of classical music.You're comparable to modern art critics. Give me one good reason why Tchaikovsky is a bad (or firetruck) composer.
Vs stale mass produced guttertrash like Vivaldi he's a dream.
Benjamin Kelly
>Give me one good reason why Tchaikovsky is a bad (or firetruck) composer. His attempts at sonata allegro form are borderline embarrassing, but for some reason he kept on trying and trying.
Isaac Cruz
Not to mention there is no Universe where Hans ZImmer would be confused with any of the aforementioned artists. Zimmer does his own thing, in his own niche, and he would agree. He might use the same instruments as some of these classical composers but the similarity ends there.
Lincoln Parker
My absolute favorite is Mendelssohn. I also like Brahams, Dvorak, and Chopin.
Levi Nguyen
It's so cute when Romantic kids seize on an innovative master like Vivaldi as an object of scorn.
Nathan Clark
I don't think I like Richard Wagner. Sure he hated the jews, but he was pretty degenerate revolutionary. Fascinating fellow, but Michael E Jones's research makes me distrust him.
Ryder Clark
And this discounts his Waltzes and Ballets? You have shit taste.
Next you'll be telling me about being classically trained. Kek.
The waltz is not a serious genre, and ballet didn't get (musically) interesting until Stravinsky.
I wasn't going to mention it, but I did in fact major in music.
Josiah Flores
To the dilettante I was recently engaging with on here: in the last classical thread:
All baroque composers borrowed music. It is what they did with the borrowings that counts. Bach never wrote an original chorale, he borrowed all of them. Handel, as one critic said, changed rocks into diamonds when he borrowed. You are in the .0001 group who thinks Vivaldi is greater than Handel. He is not even in the same league.
I am extremely well informed having worked in musicology for years. Insecurity does not exist for me, because I don't debate things I know nothing about. Music is for me the grandest art and when crape comes out of mouths like yours, I speak up, and I can back up it up. So be careful.
If you love Vivaldi fine, but you cross the line when you compare his music to the greatest Baroque composers. I would in addition to the great two, Handel and Bach, rate several other composers of the time over Vivaldi. There is no arguing about taste, that is why your comments on Vivaldi are valid. But that does not change the fact that your principal statement (that Vivaldi is superior) is agreed upon by an extremely small minority.
You are also uniformed on Handel's borrowings (a common practice in the Baroque Era). Go to the Handel forum and read the papers on his borrowing and how he could transform a nothing idea into a gem. You obviously have tastes of approval and disapproved that are in the minority. Vivaldi is never rated as a top master, while Wagner is. Your knowledge of music and art seems to be minimal at best. I would bet that you have never heard a Handel or Wagner opera in your life. You are a sad person indeed.
I don't expect most Jow Forumsacks to appreciate this. The counterpoint is too complex and it doesn't sound enough like movie music.
Carson Carter
Sure it is a it pedantic at times, but the elitism can also enforce standards and exclusion of degenerate musics. There is no equality in music, and I think there can be objective reasons to judge one musical art more beautiful than others.
Listen to the Olympic hymn of Richard Strauss (1936) if you want to get an idea of the Ellenic esthetic ideal of NS. m.youtube.com/watch?v=14VllN5h9xw
Brayden Ward
Chopin and Liszt are God tier for piano. Bach and Handel are untouchable as well.
Samuel Bennett
I really don't see how Tchaikovsky could be considered a composer who held bourgeoisie ideals musically, it seems rather aristocratic to me. However I really don't know much about classical beyond typical table conversation, and I don't understand music structurally other than what a key / chord / other basic information is.
Literally triggered by a meme picture. I'm embarrassed for you.
Dvorak sounds familiar, any specific pieces you like?
Baroque is hit and miss for me. I'm not fully used to the harpsichord's timbre. Will listen though.
I haven't listened to Mendelssohn or Brahms purposefully - again, any specific pieces to watch out for?
Sebastian Ramirez
This. Chopin was on another tier of his own.
Jose Jones
It would be more accurate to say that Vivaldi had five hundred ideas for a concerto, and that none of them ever was fully worked out. It is only after his wonderful opening bars, his extraordinary beginnings (which taught J. S. Bach so much), that his concertos bog down and begin to resemble each other in the deployment of harmonic cliches-cliches which would not matter (as they do not matter in Handel) if the large harmonic form were coherent and interesting, the cliches given a sense of direction and movement instead of a feeling of jogging on a treadmill.
Vivaldi's operas are coming in for attention now: the same faults and virtues are manifest there. The arias begin strikingly, but continue with little of Handel's energy, Bach's intensity, or Alessandro Scarlatti's subtlety. These deficiencies are less crippling here: an aria is generally much shorter than a concerto movement. In comparing Vivaldi to Bach and Handel, some of his admirers (Marc Pincherle, for example) either refused to face his weaknesses, or else-what is worse-they never understood the strengths of the already established masters
Overrated: Antonio Vivaldi. I'm tired of him. Stravinsky once said that Vivaldi wrote the same concerto 500 times. I disagree. Instead, I think he began 500 concertos and never achieved anything in them. So he kept trying over and over again without ever quite succeeding.
Jason Lee
Imagine eating nothing but McDonalds your whole life and arguing about food on the internet.
Jason Davis
>if you hate ZOG nigger shit you're a contrarian k
I don't care much for Vivaldi myself. But in terms of musicology, Bach, being the great synthesizer of pan-European music, learned much of his craft from writing out copies of music from Italian, English, French, Dutch music. Some of the Bach organ concertos I have looked at are direct transcriptions of Vivaldi's music. Whether you like Vivaldi of not isn't the issue. Bach himself adored and emulated Vivaldi's composition. I can't speak for Handel, but he is more of an Italian influenced composer than Bach. Handel composed many Italian language operas. So I wouldn't be surprised if he was just as influenced by Vivaldi. What is Wagner's best opera in your opinion? I heard Parsifal is good.
Eli Kelly
Rachmaninoff, Yann Tiersen, Ludovico Einaudi, Jeroen van Veen, Yiruma, Nobuyuki Tsujii. Maybe even Kjell Baekkelund and Fabrizio Paterlini aswell. All piano, non-degenerate music.
Jackson Perez
Symphony No.9, Op.95 'From the New World' (most widely known) Slavonic Dances
>Symphony No.9, Op.95 'From the New World' (most widely known) >Slavonic Dances
It's like I'm really listening to the radio.
Zachary Rogers
My favorite violin concerto. I like this recording better. youtube.com/watch?v=NTaNqM1HCeU For Brahms I recommend starting with his chamber music. The piano quintet, string quintets especially the 2nd, the cello sonatas, the clarinet ensembles, string sextets. Really there's too much to list.
Ayden Morgan
Yes yes. Now name me a mainstream piece that you genuinely enjoy.
Thanks. I like some of the effects of Wagner (the Tristan chord), but if you're bored check out Dr. Jones on Wagner's music. Kind of starts around around the first few minutes. A history of the revolution and Wagner. youtube.com/watch?v=CwaNFOtiFkY
Julian White
>Bach is overrated and technically flawed. opinion discarded
Josiah Adams
>I like Baroque, it has an elegance through minimalism kek
Funny that you bring up Civ 4. I've just discovered this not so well known flemish renaissance composer named Hieronimus Vinders. His music was featured in Civ 4 apparently.
Lol go back to freshman year music history. The ultra-pedantic fucks like you are what led to Second Viennese School garbage. I advise reading Taruskin's analysis of Tchaikovsky 4 if you want to appreciate how Tchaikovsky played around with sonata allegro form, dipshit.
>ballet didn't get (musically) interesting until Stravinsky You mean the vast majority of ballet music is boring until Rite of Spring, which effectively killed ballet? Please stop talking about music.
t. Graduated from top 5 conservatory
Angel Brooks
5.5/10
Logan Brown
>I advise reading Taruskin You Russian-infatuated types always do. Reading an analysis of Bruckner 6 would be a much more stimulating use of a person's time.
>You mean the vast majority of ballet music is boring until Rite of Spring *Les Noces
Lucas Hill
Civ 4 has the best musical composition in all of gaming. It was fucking flawless, save for the modern era, which was a bit depressing, but flawless choices for depressing music nontheless.
I tried to improve on it by adding custom tracks but it feels out of place. Top tier mein freund.
Ryan Garcia
I mean, I've heard Bach before, but it never caught my attention in the way the aforementioned composers did. Will add to my list though, thanks for the recs
Thanks, and yes, I guess my issue with baroque is not structural ( in the musical sense) but with the harpsichord. Will give these a shot.
Tbh I've spent time in/mu/ and other than the minor flamewar about Hans Zimmer, this has been better than almost any music discussion on that board.
Ryder Stewart
I remember the first piece. If you played the Renaissance era long enough it would eventually play.
That game was filled with great classical music.
Grayson Wood
No. 6 in F# minor is the other standout on that playlist, but the whole thing is worth hearing.
/mu/ is trash by the way. I used to post there as CLT.