People with finance/econ back ground or those who have looked into it a decent amount, can we win a trade war with China without things going to shit b4 2020?
Can he actually beat China in a trade war?
Other urls found in this thread:
youtu.be
youtube.com
twitter.com
Of course, god emperor Trump, our greatest ally, can archieve anything! God Bless him!
who cares? the USA ultimately isn't going to be able to compete on the world stage for much longer unless we get fairer trade deals. i think in USA v The World, The World will prob win, but we've go to try.
Obama's policy of "lets just give everything the USA has to the rest of the world" was essentially legit traitorous and i still think he should be hanged for it.
Don't care. I voted for him to blow up the world's economy.
Easily. China is not food nor energy independent. The US is very close to being both.
If the US gets hurt 5%, the rest of the world will hurt 15%
also obligatory "not a threat to the former president" - like i think he should be tried and found guilty of treason, then hanged by the state.
man it sucks being cucked to stupid laws like this one. even kathy griffin shouldn't have gotten a visit from the secret service IHMO. nor stupid madonna.
Of course. The US has the capacity to do damn near anything if it really wants to. At best China might be clever enough to jocky out a better global position than we'd like, but too far and the whole world suffers when the US suffers.
Of course not. Burgerstan is living on borrowed time and nothing drumpf does will change that.
Econ here
We can absolutely win a trade war with China. Their economy is still dependent on running a trade surplus to sustain their growth.
Xi and the Reds are being stupid and foolish for not bowing to the demand for reciprocity. Their policy of devaluation makes imports unattractive, so there's no risk of their markets suddenly being flooded with goods
Easy. Chinese Achilles heel is NLP (non-performing loans). They are doing $800B of fake loan "stimulus" every month. House of cards. $200B in tariffs will cause those to collapse. Once that collapses then unemployment shoots to 45%. Once that happens, china goes back to being the fractured, split, regional backwater its been for 3000 yrs.
And that's only looking at it from a financial angle. There are tons of other ways to make life unpleasant for China if they really want a fight.
This. As much as the MSM likes to reee about Trump burning bridges with all our allies the fact is we don't really need any of them. We could easily become an isolationist country again and be just fine, while China's economy is based on manufacturing things for cheap and selling them back to us at high prices. In the long run if we broke off trade relations with China entirely it would ultimately fuck them and help us. Prices of manufactured goods would probably go up for us but our economy would be stronger since more people would be working and thus would have more buying power.
>cutting off your nose to spite your face
why are trump supporters so retarded?
Trade wars don't have winners.
Trade war is literally codeword for lets kill the monetary system.
Doubt it. China is a dictatorship, so it can't really "lose" until the Chinese government can't afford to pay the military. Trump "loses" the moment his popularity in swing states drops 5%.
Nobody's nose is being cut off. It's just strong-armed bargaining. It's not in China's interest to take things far enough that it winds up hurting too much. If it wants to play hard ball as much as it thinks it can, then that's its geopolitical perogative.
>can the USA beat China
In summary, yes.
The USA has historically been a manufacturing powerhouse. We are still a world leader in manufacturing.
If factories lay dormant or had continued to shut down for 2 or 3 more decades, then we might be unable to fight back.
As it stands, we still have the economy, the workforce, the innovation, and the tooling to make whatever we want.
We still have foundries, we still have plastics production, we have everything. It has just been cheaper to outsource.
China is an export economy specializing in producing outsourced products for export. Few chinese can afford what they are producing.
We have domestic production, domestic consumption, intellectual property, we really have all the cards.
china's stock market is crashing as we speak. they have too much credit debt and its all sub-national and held by shadow corporations that took free gibmes from the government and insane bank loans. they have had over 50% credit debt ration growth in the past 5 years. countries that experienced 30% in 5 years all had collapses out of the 43 instances of it. and china is fucking double most of them in this category. they are fucked.
as for america, they are the only market for the chinese garbage that can buy enough of it. they have no one else to sell all that shit to. tariffs on us shit is going to bite them in the ass. they cant win this war. they are beyond fucked. its why they are trying to buddy up with india lately.
>lets hurt our economy so we can hurt other economies even more!!!
fucking idiot
Trump has already (wisely) backed away from his earlier stupid ideas about tariffs. Actual economists probably got hold of him and slapped him in the mouth.
He isn't gonna do jack shit. He's a Fake President. Nobody gives one fuck about Dump's useless, stupid ass.
>Their policy of devaluation makes imports unattractive
why this? and also if this is true then how would we win it? the trade deficit would stay the same, but we cash in on tariffs i guess?
>china buddy with india lately
What did they do? Last I had a look it seemed like they were continuing on with the new silk road plans that involved a China-Pakistan axis vs. a US-India axis. Have they taken tactical steps to try to avoid having the China-India antagonism exploited?
>China is a dictatorship
That hasnt stopped them from losing every defensive war and collapsing every 200 years for the entirety of their existence
Trump Accomplishments: NONE
Nah, China is already too big and powerful. America is fucked! It is not longer king of the globe.
If USA can snag 3% GDP growth for the year (most execs think this is easy for the year) with the tariffs imposed then I don't see why not. Trump will be able to get anything he wants out of Euro and Brit trade deals also if we log a 3% GDP increase with these tariffs. China is a bigger house of cards than USA by far.
Are you talking about the US or China? This is a long-term positive for the US despite whatever temporary reallocation we have to suffer through. China's only in to hurt here as much as it wants to hurt in the name of trying to plan its own future.
>America is the only market for Chinese garbage
Nice try leaf. I've been to Canadian Tyre, seen your walmarts, and you fuckers buy as much chinese made crap as us.
Why is anyone holding the Yuan right now?
(You)
>$200B in tariffs will cause those to collapse
kek. why would this affect theyre ability to use nlp's?
no he is an idiot. its not war its diplomacy. war is just a tool of diplomacy. he only used the stick he needs a carrot too. he has been completly unable to provide any carrots. neither in his negotions with china, germany or the eu in general. be it the topic of nato spending, trade imbalance or iran. no carrots in sight only threats.
They already got their carrots. Don't be salty.
why are pinkos obsessed with calling everyone retarded? Are you, dare i say it, retarded?
You kraut-niggers have been doing nothing but bitching about Trump all day. Pay your debts!
Yes, all those other ways are already baked into the cake. The idea of a "unified china" is a myth. Its a mirage caused by 100 yrs of American superpower status. Out of Chinese 3000+ yr history, about 150 yrs have been unified. Out of those 150 yrs of unification, none lasted more than 40 yrs, except this one time when a place called America subsidized the worlds security.
Once the subsidy machine is shutoff, all those preexisting pressures will come back to the surface. HK vs Shanghai vs Beijing vs countryside. Easy peasy
Stink bait. Must be catfishing
Well he's a selfish, egocentric spoiled little asshole. (Emphasis on 'little'). Big babies like him (I love the balloon!) can eat a dick and fuck off. He does not represent America and never will. We want his diseased ass GONE.
Yes and very easily. They can't match us dollar for dollar on tarrifs, our tarrifs on the EU and Canada eliminate their economic proxies right out the bat, China has no sort of force projection that can back them up and the chinks are surrounded by Asian enemies that America will use against them to put the squeeze on. China is barely functioning as it is and an economic downturn caused by trade war with America will turn into full blown revolution if they don't bend the knee. The exporter always is at a disadvantage in a trade dispute and China is one of the biggest. America doesn't have that sort of vulnerability. America is also food independent and nearly energy independent. The only weakness at the moment is the 2018 race that might be jeopardized by temporary economic downturn caused by a trade war but so far it looks like a clean sweep for the GOP dispute "blue wave" memes.
That's my analysis at least.
Weak bait
Threats seem to be working. What are the other countries going to do, not use the dollar?
And we've already made strategic inroads with both NK and India. Somebody has been thinking ahead for once.
Truth hurts, don't it?
Triggering your pathetic ass is all I need to maga 2020 faggot
China has serious and systemic debt problems across all sectors. They're in a very fragile place and have a lot to lose.
Trump has a lot to lose, too; but in a war of attrition, China will come out of it far worse.
Fuck yourself faggot. Take a stroll wearing your KKK red hat and we'll show you what America thinks of fucking faggot lowlife bitch Trump.
Again, fuck off.
The devaluation of the Yuan makes American exports more expensive relative to the Chinese.
That doesn't mean no imports won't take place. But with the non-monetary trade barriers that China has, it's difficult if not impossible for American firms to sell their products even if they wanted to
youtu.be
EVERY PATRIOT WATCH AND LAUGH AS THE WORLD COLLAPSES AROUND US AND WE WATCH WITH A NICE COLD BEER
Short answer: yes
>it's a long term positive to piss off allies and other countries we've had generally good diplomatic and business relations with
the NLP is the measure of how many "bad loans" there are in an economy. China claims 0% (all loans are good).
200B in tariffs will remove lots of money from the debtors ability to pay back said loans. Once they can't pay back then Chinese banks can't issue new loans...the whole fake economy comes to a halt rather quickly and violently.
Krauts are smarting hard from Trump's dick slap of Herr Merkel. Be grateful that he didn't pants her on live TV
you think a fat, balding pervert who never worked a day in his life is some icon of masculinity. you'd have to be pretty fucking retarded to believe that.
so what you're saying is that he's accomplished more in 18 months than obama in 96
HAHAHAHA NO CAN BEAT THE GOOD OLE USA USA USA USA USA USA USA
China isn't an ally. It's just another country and it doesn't need to get its fee-fees hurt if we'd like to negotiate a more reasonable relationship.
This salt will go well with my popcorn
lol yeah we'll have the economic powerhouse of north korea on our side, what a plan.
That wasn't just Obama, that was every presidency since end of WW2.
LOL. Can u even read? Trump is a fucking FAGGOT. A worhtless pile of dog shit. Eat a dick losers. Eat Patriot cock!
Yes we definitely can. China's economy is a bin of cloth, it can fit alot and the pile can get huge but all it takes is a match to burn it out. The problem with China is the low purchasing power of the consumers, Americans as a comparison have some of the highest purchasing power on Earth. Because of this and because we still have means of self growing food and manufacturing, we can sustain ourselves on our own resources and afford them because our purchasing power only increases as factories revive.
China on the otherhand can produce alot of product for cheap but their own people cannot afford these products. This causes a serious inbalance of supply and demand and its this scale that really works against the chinese and would send their country back 100 years economically.
They have only been doing western econokics for 70 years whereas the US has been doing it for hundreds of years. We have an overwhelming advantage when it comes to export trades and self reliance and because Trump is trying to push for it the other countries of the world are getting scared of the balance of trade power shifting back to the US
did I say china was an ally? holy shit you have the reading comprehension of Trump.
but let me guess, the pan-sexual canadian devient is something to behold, right?
is obama's cock in your arse or mouth as you type this?
>Trump has a lot to lose, too
eh. Total US economy, 7.9% is result of foreign trade. We are largest economy and least integrated. A one-time 8% hit to our GDP is 'bad' but completely manageable. For China foreign trade represents the majority of economy, so its terminal.
the threats arent working though. the iran deal still stands for everyone but the usa. north stream 2 is still being build. american tarrifs are still met with counter tarrifs. and germany is still going take its sweet ass time to reach 2 percent military spending if ever (not that I would mind seeing the bundeswehr getting money).
NK's importance is geopolitical, not economic. I guess it could be economic depending on how the future of possible Korean reunification goes, but it's predominantly important to usurp China's influence over it.
my god, you're pathetic. why don't you focus on what you're good at - rolling a doobie... well, and not much else.
worthless loser.
Yep.
I wonder if you're a faggot that's actually retarded enough to think that's what we're doing, or if you get paid to shill your faggotry here. God your job must suck.
Back during the cold war, it was a necessity to secure American interests (i.e. unite historical enemies against the Soviets). It's been almost 30 years since the USSR fell and we've been on autopilot. We're keeping a system that used to make sense and is now obsolete. Trump is simply making changes that should have been made in 1991.
Man I hope the rope your neighbors use on you is MADE IN THE USA
Yeah just stop trading with them and call yourself Peoples Republic of North America. You already have a senile, old wigger. You'll win for sure. Best Luck.
Think about it. Do you think we would be doing this if we didn't think we'd win it?
>can't express himself without referencing his desertjuden life manual
Trump is a living God and China will bend the knee.
don't blame him. he's been radicalised by CNN and MSNBC, and isn't smart enough to see through it.
perhaps if his mom hadn't dropped him on his head as a baby. repeatedly.
>allies
That's a funny way to spell leeches.
He probably believes what he's saying. I monitor some left-leaning analysts and they've gone into surprising contortions coming up with lines of reasoning to justify a knee-jerk anti-Trump narrative rather than their usual habit of looking for ways to steer the status quo in a useful direction given that it is what it is.
Yes. Easily. China is not independent and a vast majority of the country is dirt poor. They've come a long way in the last few decades but still nowhere near self sufficient. On top of that you are basically asking if China can beat the global market powerhouse since everything is traded on the petrodollar. Hell if the US imposed sanctions on them China would erupt in a civil war within the year. Anyone who even thinks china has any say in this is probably being ignorant on purpose.
Don't worry
We will supply them
funny coming from the country with a massive and rising debt problem. our debt isnt growing, its stagnated and we even started reducing it. and nato isnt an extension of americas military budget we dont owe you shit.
>b-but obama
haha every time. You dimwits really can't deal with the fact that you're so fucking pathetic even trump looks masculine next to you.
Can he? More like how fast can he make China bend the knee.
Had a move like this happened in the early 90s...yes.
Due to crumbling infrastructure in 2019 this will end up in a third world status for the USA.
You can blame the Clintons for helping the Chinese flood the world with their cheap shit.
The clintons sold out the USA
>possible korean unification
you retards still hoping for that huh? maybe add some actual value to the commemorative coins trump scammed you with?
Look at this faggot
yeah but only because european monetary policy is exclusively setup to benefit krauts
at the cost of club med
>the rest of the world wouldnt start sucking our dicks to get back onto good terms with us
They are barking but dont have the bite to back it up
here's your (you)
Trump is the prime example of Dunning–Kruger effect. Prove me wrong pro tip, you can't.
NATO
>Only focuses on monetary value.
>Only want to make a deal, doesn't understand long term relationships.
>What is not 100% alignment of interest (does he expect to rule all of the west)
>What is arms Sales to allies, and control over supply of equipment and spare parts
>What is cloud?
>What is power projection (why does the US spend so much more)
>What is the Petro dollar.
>What is reserve currency.
>What is foreign trust in T-bonds.
The US holds all the cards. Why is he so hellbent on destroying the American global order?
youtube.com
TRADE WAR
>US "wins"
> US gives up its leverage over China.
>Labor market gets clouded, Wages go up for the lower class
>More US niggers get jobs, and more wealth.
>Niggers demand more money.
>Niggers get uppity.
>No abortion rights
>More Niggers
>Make America Black again
hey man you had you empire that you set for your own benefit. dont get yelly if others do the same.
>The problem with China is the low purchasing power
this makes sense. two things tho:
1) isnt china middle class fairly large now?
2) this still sounds like american consumers will get hit so will the effect be bad enough to get Trump kicked out in 2020 if this "war" continues?
nope
>being this butthurt
lmaoing at your life
haha you're seriously fucking delusional. Trump is a retard and has no idea what he's doing. You fucking morons just salivate at the mouth everytime he tries to act tough.
For all the literal retards out there.... CHINA DOES NOT SURVIVE WITHOUT USA CONSUMPTION. WE HOLD ALL THE CARDS. CHINA EITHER AGREES TO OUR TRADE DEMANDS OR INDIA BECOMES THE REPLACEMENT. END OF STORY.
Nobody really wins a trade war.
But China could do other things. Like stop buying US bonds and so stop financing US debt.
They could also strike more bilateral deals with trading partners which would be cleared in their own currencies. Basically they could continue to undermine the dollar.
yeah i guess it'd been better, had trump given best korea $5bn and nuclear technology in return for nothing
Found the lefty faggot. Do you still have dried up semen in your brain from when Barry O and the media skull fucked you for 8 years? Better get CHECKED
this. /threadly/