Property is that which exists my one's labour.
>but stealing IP has no bad effects
Wrong!
When you steal IP, its originator's ability to profit from its use is impaired.
Intellectual Property is VALID
Bentley Torres
Samuel Bailey
problem is rarely do the creators/originators get paid because of loans, licensing, manufacturing, distribution, corporations and banks who profit from the concept.
IBM holds the most unused patents because they're not profitable even though they can improve the quality of life.
That's what you're defending
shit eating cut-dick retarded kike
Ethan Johnson
>originators don't get paid much of profit
Nice spin on the "exploitation of laborers by skimming excess value," Marx.
>IBM holds patents unused in order to spite people.
You have tools you don't use everyday- as such, YOUR OWNERSHIP IS THEFT.
Benjamin Jenkins
funny seeing a chinaman arguing in favor of IP
James Cook
>all leafs are Chinese
No. Only a tiny % of Canada is Chinese. Like 3%.
Eli Jackson
knowledge is not theft. application of knowledge is not theft
Jordan Flores
100% of Canadians capable of removing their dicks from their dogs for long enough to type a comment are Chinese.
Connor White
>application of knowledge is not theft
It is IF the knowledge was not given to you voluntarily.
Grayson White
Canada did not legalize beastility, only the ability of butchers to LEGALLY butcher animals. It was clearing a technicality that now technically allows certain sex acts with animals.
Luke Wilson
>knowledge is not theft. application of knowledge is not theft
Stealing knowledge is theft
Levi Ramirez
> now technically allows certain sex acts with animals
> technically allows
> certain sex acts with animals
Camden Reyes
>stealing is not theft
Are you Black?
Jaxon Scott
>it's legal to fuck dogs
It's legalization did not mean more people did it.
Jaxon Sullivan
>ability to profit
usury is a death sentence
Josiah Williams
>it's not theft to steal information
>that people spent much time discovering
>which is only known because of the people who worked for it
You only think knowledge is not theft...because you don't think.
Henry Fisher
Being alive is a death sentence
Dylan Phillips
>Stealing knowledge is theft
>Stealing atoms is theft
>Stealing air is theft
>Stealing existence is theft
Austin Sullivan
ok but not as fast
Oliver Perez
>usary is bad
>because the fact that something is known/exists means I should profit from it
>even if I don't pay for it
Ryan Brooks
Finally somebody who can think clearly
Joseph Martin
>Stealing knowledge is theft
Yes
>Stealing atoms is theft
Depends if they are under someone's ownership.
>Stealing air is theft
Depends if they are under someone's ownership.
>Stealing existence is theft
Check your premises.
Michael Torres
Nope.
Hunter Roberts
> Ming-chi typed, taking a brief moment from sodomizing his Jack Russel Terrier and verbally berating his Canadian maid.
Adrian White
Jose Reed
No one has the sole ownership of knowledge you plebs.
Michael Wilson
Also stealing reflected light via photography is theft.
Leo Robinson
"Intellectual Property" is in DIRECT contradiction with actual property.
Isaac Richardson
Obviously
Connor Jackson
No.
Oliver Stewart
Right now I have knowledge that is my sole property, as long as I don't tell anyone.
Asher Peterson
business secrets can be privately owned and therefore be "illegaly stolen".
but copying something you see in public or copying something you own? how the hell would that be "theft"?
Oliver Campbell
Your post is in DIRECT contradiction with reality.
Anthony Hill
what you implied has nothing to do with what I said.
but whatever, you're still a brain damaged kike
Camden Scott
That is something Satan would say.
Brody Green
"but copying something you see in public or copying something you own? how the hell would that be "theft"?"
>it's not stealing if they can't catch me
You have some nigger in you.
Austin Powell
abandoning brain damaged OP's thread
Nathaniel Wright
>can't into comparisons
Too many dog dicks.
Joshua Ramirez
you just copied my post. that's illegal. did i give you permission to copy my comment? i don't think so. my comment is my private intellectual property and only allowed to be posted by me. stop being a nigger.
Grayson White
>When you steal IP, its originator's ability to profit from its use is impaired.
Nope. When you share it, it could be. But more than likely whoever is 'taking' it wouldn't have spent any money and just did without.
>logic
>flawed
Brandon Collins
Heres the meme you faggot
>lets say that knowledge is a dollar bill
>I own the dollar bill
>I give someone else the dollar bill
>that person now has the dollar bill
>Do I still have my own dollar bill?
Yes because I duplicated it when I gave it away.
Thats the mindset of abundance. You all have a Jewish mindset of scarcity
robertdavidsteele.com
Zachary Garcia
Reminder
Mason Reed
>he doesn't know why it's bad if everybody makes counterfeit dollar bills
Ethan Carter
>When you steal IP, its originator's ability to profit from its use is impaired.
So... the creator makes less money. I have no money. Do you think I give a single fuck about how much money this other person is making?
also
>Canadian
every time
Dylan Collins
Dollar bills are a bad example because >fiat currency
Think about this, I have a barrel of gasoline for my car. I use it to fuel my car. If I give a duplicate to someone else he can fuel his car, and I can still fuel mine.
Juan Barnes
No, but dollar bills are good examples because dollar bills are only valuable if they're scarce.
Similarly, knowledge creation is only valuable if knowledge is scarce.
There's no incentive for people to value (and pay for) knowledge creation if it is very abundant. People are incentivized to simply wait around and be free riders.
If
Jason Howard
IP is fine within the lifetime of the creator.
It's after their death that it gets kind of ridiculous.
William Jenkins
IP is certainly a good thing, until people file vague as fuck patents specifically for the purpose of suing the shit out of innovators.
Also this
Ian Lopez
no sane person believes that intellectual property is valid past 50+ years though, the laws in america are outrageous.
Christian Ross
like I said. You have a Jewish mindset of scarcity.
Thomas Gomez
Jacob Torres
ok atoms was a bad premise but conflating "air" (meaning the stuff that just sits here on earth all over the place) with captured gases is sematic bullshit. my point is that it is imposible to steal intangible things, it is simply jewish moneygrubbing.
>oy vey! youre so stupid if you dont get these cultural references!
>now pay up or you dont get to be 'in', goy!
Jayden Hill
The patenting proccess doesn't seem that great, we should be encouraging people to put useful ideas to work for society
Joshua James
>He doesn't know why it's bad if everybody makes counterfeit dollar bills
It doesn't matter if you use the word "jewish" to describe a process in reality.
It's not my mindset that controls the world, it's physical law.
Luis Hill
But, just so you know, "abundance" or "ubuntu" is a nigger concept from africa. And that's what you are.
Brayden Cook
you can own ideas...
Ian Fisher
>ability to profit from its use is impaired.
Cry me a river.