archive.fo/9v9KS >Jewish social media is abuzz about dual loyalty following a controversy involving Congresswomen Rashida Tlaib. Accusation and counter-accusation have followed, with various defenders arguing that various dual loyalty charges are false and slanderous.
>I want to argue something different: The charge is true, but so what? Dual loyalties are good, natural and widespread.
>I write as a proud American Jew who feels strong loyalty to both the U.S.A. and Israel, and I write anonymously because this topic provokes vehemence from both anti-Semites and understandably hyper-vigilant Jews. But someone needs to say it.
>I can understand the reluctance to do so among Jews. Dual loyalty accusations singling out Jews are part of a longstanding set of tropes and stereotypes that, together, fuel anti-Semitism and even murder and genocide.
>The hateful tone and selective application of dual loyalty accusations towards Jews is unquestionably vile.
>And yet, one reason they stick is that they’re true.
>Jews classically have considered ourselves a distinct nation, wherever located — and not always by choice. The anti-Semitism of the countries in which we spent the majority of our Diaspora years have treated us as strangers in a strange land, creating even deeper bonds and loyalties and reliance upon each other to survive.
>Only in the Enlightenment did the concept of nationhood expand to allow Jewish membership in other nations. And that change had a price: erasing Jewish nationhood.
>.Jews received European emancipation as individuals, but implicitly (or explicitly) had to consider themselves not Jewish nationals but “Frenchmen [e.g.] of the Mosaic faith.” Judaism became an ethno-religious identity rather than a national one.
>This bargain was a mixed blessing. On the one hand, Jews were happy to be considered equal to their co-nationalists. On the other hand, the fact of Jewish nationhood did not cease to exist just because it became inconvenient. This question became only more complicated for Diaspora Jews with the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. Where did that leave American or French Jews? Were they part of the Jewish nation and its nation state, or their home countries?
>The truth is, we Diaspora Jews are both members of the Jewish nation and members of the nations in which we live. We are loyal to the Jewish people and to the American people, in my case. And despite the claims of some anti-Semites, whose accusations of “dual loyalty” imply true loyalty to Israel and false loyalty to America, we love both countries equally and fervently.
Kek. You're such a retard you're expecting people to trust the WALL STREET JOURNAL owned by RUPERT MURDOCH. Bolton's words + reality today speaks volumes more than fake news articles with anonymous sources.
If you're trying to convince anyone that Bolton isn't one of the biggest shabbos goy's in history you're gonna need to do a better job Kushnershill.
Hudson Davis
Im not trying to convince anyone. People are entitled to come to their own conclusions. You're the person trying to force a monolithic narrative.
Jack Gonzalez
>is true >but so what if this doesn't make your blood boil, i don't know what will
Dylan Cook
bump
Connor Morales
after a little digging, from the foia thread earlier i found that the Congressional Research Service is the government agency that keeps records of congressmen (age, marital status, religion, etc).
Except citizenship (or dual citizenship) isnt listed as one of the fields of record they keep.
www.crsreports.congress.gov
Lucas Martin
>the charge is true, but so what The audacity
Nicholas White
Hitler was right and did nothing wrong.
Daniel Thomas
The author is such a coward that they couldn't even use their own name.
>Isn't white nationalism a form of dual loyalty? White Nationalism is a zionist psy op. It's a made up buzzword to dismiss anything that doesn't go with the zionist agenda.
>Burgers will accept this >Burgers will keep sending Israel billions >Burgers will go to war in Iran for Israel Are Americans the biggest cucks on the planet who bully Sweden to project away from their own castration, excuse me, *circumcision*? Why YES of course they are!
First the Jew took your dicklet, then he took your nation.
So much bark on this dog. Guess that's why the "Yankee" label stuck.
Ethan Foster
>schizo posting You guys never learn do you? I guess you're legitimately too stupid to shill without buzzwords. It's okay though. Soon HUMANITY will unite to genocide every single zionist.
Juan Wilson
>Merkel personally phoned European leaders not to move embassy to Jerusalem happened and not one did move >Iran deal kept >Ameriniggers threatening us and for Russia we keep trading >No Zog wars >Schröder kept us out of Iraq entirely with Chirac >Calling out false flags and American imperialism before it was cool Europe is dominated by leftists, not Israel
Once Israel is wiped off the map all the refugees will go back home, where they belong. Fuck Israel.
Carson Diaz
You are mentally insane, dude and especially annoying. If you intend to spam and shit up the board, whatever. You are an endless supply of crap and strawmen screencaps for JIDF. Fantastic job, peabrain!
Their criticism of Sweden is fair but it's no doubt that Americans lack self awareness on a whole.
Christian Robinson
bump
Jayden Murphy
bump.
Benjamin Wright
>Dual loyalties are good, For Israel >natural For jews >and widespread. Among the jews and their pawns
David Collins
OH shit this is big the JQ will be discussed
Colton Peterson
bump.
Ayden Cruz
bump.
Sebastian Mitchell
It's funny because it uses the same type of language that modern MSM pieces use to try to shove their bolshevik trash down our throats, as if it wasn't obvious enough that the jew thrives using these tactics
