>What’s odd, though, is that becomes the all encompassing thing to you.
How is that odd? Sex is biologically an all encompassing activity, involving body and mind. I have friends with which I like listening to metal, I have friends with which I like playing videogames, with others I drink beer... We share an interest, and that's fine, friends are what make life interesting and worthy (most of times). But sex (or should I say love?) goes beyond that: which brings me to the next point
>You want to have sex with her so badly that everything else about her is suddenly unimportant in comparison?
In fact, that's exactly the opposite: everything about her it's important to me, and THAT'S WHY I want to have sex with her.
Again, I'll reverse that: so many things about me are good (in "your" own words) and YET that's not enough to have sex?
>Because you can appreciate attractive qualities without actually desiring them. I’m a straight woman and can tell when other women are very attractive, and how they can do things to make themselves more attractive. That doesn’t mean I want to be with them. Similarly, I can tell when a guy has attractive qualities other girls will like, but not ones that click for me.
Yeah, don't worry, I've already heard this story: and, AGAIN, it's not even self-consistent (not that I expect it to be, since it comes from a woman: no offense intended, I've already noticed your kind just does not get the point, or pretends not too).
"I can tell when a guy has attractive qualities other girls will like, **but not ones that click for me**. "
But these girls literally just told me that they like my qualities :O --- "I like your qualities, but not like I really like them, you know? I like them, but I don't, actually." --- "My boyfriends beats me. I like that I can talk to you about that, you respect women" [actual conversation happened with multiple girls]
...Seriously? You don't see any problem with such statements?