Was he a War Hero or a War Criminal?
Was he a War Hero or a War Criminal?
Andrew Hernandez
Other urls found in this thread:
youtu.be
critical-theory.com
twitter.com
Brayden Roberts
He's a War Criminal that should have been tried and executed for the innocent lives he killed.
Charles Hughes
The answer to said type of question can usually be answered with the same one you'd provide to: "did their side win?"
Tyler Parker
Both depending on who you ask
Evan Miller
A great man. After his son died during the war, I think it hardened him considerably. He also considered the rebellion to be an affront against God himself.
Hunter Perez
"Did their side win?"
Yes
"Was he a war hero or a war criminal?"
Yes
i don't understand your reasoning bro
Jackson White
>War Hero or a War Criminal?
Both of these ideas are fucking stupid and made up by retards who have never fought in a war.
Jordan Reyes
he forced civilians to evacuate before he burned their homes and infrastructure to the ground
Dominic Howard
Did his side win:
Yes, hero
No, criminal
How is that hard?
Jackson Brown
yes
Asher Gonzalez
The problem is your mandate of placing righteousness with victory, nigger
David Kelly
Levi Rogers
Justin Torres
let the secesh sizzle
Lincoln Thomas
That's how it is.
Colton Powell
Yes.
Noah Ward
-War Criminal
This is a word made up by crybabies, civilians are important war time resources, either summary execution or slave labor should be standard solution
Brayden Collins
DO IT AGAIN, UNCLE BILLY
Ian Sullivan
>hero
>criminal
Who cares. He was successful because he was a student of history with the courage to take action that assured victory.
>rules
Have no place in war.
Bentley Bennett
To be a war criminal you have to be on the losing side, so he is automatically disqualified. However, he did commit war crimes.
Camden Cook
DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY
Andrew Morales
“War crimes” are simply tactics the enemy will punish you personally for if your side loses.
Connor Reyes
DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY
Tyler Butler
>Caring about a war that happened 150 years ago
Both sides are plebs
Jayden Reed
Race traitor
Cooper Taylor
>implying he had a choice
He knew the south would continue to hold out and he was banished by time to be unable to nuke the place, so he burned the mother fucker down.
The southerners will was great at one time.
Colton Allen
Nathaniel Reyes
Do it again, uncle billy!
Nathan Russell
He should have killed every last one of those traitorous secessionists Southern scum. Burned the entire land, crop and buildings to cleanse the filth of slavery from this country so we could start fresh. But it's ok, we'll do that now.
>the North remembers
Justin Lewis
TURN AND BURN THE SECESH BASED FIREMAN
Blake Russell
>The problem is your mandate of placing righteousness with victory, nigger
That's how things work. Do you not understand that? At all?
Colton Martinez
Luftwaffe pilot who shoots at USAAF parachutes == War Criminal
USAAF pilot who shoots at Luftwaffe parachutes == War Hero
Its that simple
Jose Bailey
Are you North or South of the Mason Dixon Line?
Ethan Parker
Kill em' again Uncle Billy! Fucking southern pieces of shit need to burn again!
Landon Russell
Well, take Sir Francis Drake. The Spanish all despise him, but to the British, he's a hero, and they idolize him.
Michael Walker
victory needs no explanation you fucking southern traitor shits
Evan King
Considering how he raped, pillaged, and plundered his way through, by ordinary standards, he was a war criminal. But such a standard of classification is limiting. If I were in his shoes, I wouldn't have down it any differently. It was effectively military stratagem. It was also evil, but war itself is evil. It's only a shame the north didn't catch fire too
Easton Reyes
Do it again, Uncle Billy
Isaac Adams
(((Yankees))) not even once.
Zachary Martin
DO IT AGAIN, UNCLE BILLY
Nicholas Cook
I'm from Waco, Texas
Charles Rivera
DO IT AGAIN, UNCLE BILLY
Adam Hughes
Both.
Xavier Phillips
LETS KILL THE WHITE SOUTHERNS THEY ARE JUST SCUM! DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY DO IT AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!!
Gabriel Miller
DO IT AGAIN, UNCLE BILLY
Gavin Sanders
Kike shills are at it again
Mason Perry
DO IT AGAIN, UNCLE BILLY
Gavin Lewis
Agreed, all white southerners need to die, they are scum. Lincoln was right to align with Karl Marx in the end! Bible belt needs to burn all over again.
critical-theory.com
Jaxson Cox
>LETS KILL THE WHITE SOUTHERNS
lol lets secede and attack fort sumter and pretend to be the victims for over 100 years
lets also send a bunch of poor non-slave owning white men to fight for our right to not pay slaves a quarter at the end of the week
tldr the south was retarded
Joseph Ward
Yup kill the white southerns, racist pieces of shit deserve to burn for their anti-semetism and slavery. Evil vile christcucks.
Joshua Ramirez
I don't get what the insistence was with forcibly stopping secession. Wouldn't it have made more sense to just let them leave than to blow lives and resources on a war to stop them? As horrible as it was, I get the feeling that slavery would have eventually disappeared as technology advanced.
Cameron Rivera
>I get the feeling that slavery would have eventually disappeared as technology advanced.
the South was almost frozen in time compared to the North
Nathaniel Harris
They were downright primitive. By conquering them and bringing them back into the fold, we did them a favor. They still haven't fully recovered from their ludditism, but they're a lot better off than they would have been.
Carter Gomez
We need to just kill off the rest of the south to be honest, they serve no purpose but voting Red constantly, and are a bunch pyscho white trash with guns and the bible.
Wyatt Jones
To be a criminal, he would have to had violated laws of war in effect at that time. I don’t know what, if any laws were then applicable. It’s like the butthurt Jap apologists claiming that the atomic bombings were war crimes. They weren’t, and I suspect Sherman’s actions were similarly legal.
Nolan Jones
...
Anthony Carter
My grandad once said
>"History is written by winners, and those southern boys can do neither."
Sebastian Bennett
Fuck off discord tranny
Daniel Fisher
Stfu anti-semite. The south is filled with rascists and anti-semites like yourself. You may own all the firearms you want, but the Military would crush you all over again.
Exactly, Southerns are subhuman trash and don't deserve to exist.
Oliver Sanders
Fuck off back to pol you anti-semetic piece of shit neo-nazi. Southerners like yourself deserve to burn all over again. Lincoln knew the South was to free thinking and he had Marx assisting with that. You are still pathetically racist and are on the wrong side of history. Just like you were during the Civil War, and just like you will all over again.
Jose Rodriguez
You are as much a traitor as those southern racists, and you all burn the same.
Luis Gonzalez
South deserves to burn for racism, and so do you. African Americans and Hispanics Americans deserve this Nation more than you do. You whites destroyed this Nation and the world, can you all just fucking die off already?
Tyler Edwards
You're as much a traitor as they were, tyranny comes from many sources. They wanted to play aristocrat, but it look's like you'd prefer to be fuhrer.
Parker James
>Cherokee deserves to burn for racism, and so do you. Europeans and Hispanics Americans deserve this Nation more than you do. You tribals destroyed this country and the world, can you all just fucking die off already?
Jonathan Anderson
That's pretty great
Christian Carter
Stfu neo-nazi. Whites will burn for the shit they caused. North and South, you're so divided it's great. We will take this Nation back and make it culturally diverse where no one will be afraid of whites oppressing them any longer. Fuck off back to pol.
Henry Miller
Kill yourself mangled tranny freak, no ones falling for your kike lies anymore
Sebastian Butler
Whites killed Indians, Africans, Hispanics, everyone. You don't deserve this Nation you fought a war and killed your kind, thats how vile and viscous you whites are. Fuck off neo-nazi back to pol. DO IT AGAIN DADDY SHERMAN! KILL THE SOUTH AGAIN! DO IT AGAIN DADDY SHERMAN!
Wyatt Scott
Fuck you gun grabber scum
Josiah Adams
The only thing diverse will be whats wrapped around your neck faggot
Michael Gomez
Neo-nazi white shitlords, enjoy posting from moms basement. Racism is horrible and you are going to suffer for it. DO IT AGAIN DADDY SHERMAN DO IT AGAIN DADDY SHERMAN DO IT AGAIN DADDY SHERMAN!
Thomas Morris
>The scheme's of ethnic group X are destroying this country
>We can only preserve the nation by reverting to something that never existed
You're the Nazi here bud.
Josiah Cruz
Back to your discord chat shill
Justin Edwards
Yeah, those hispanics really were the victims in the Americas.
Aaron Green
DO IT AGAIN, UNCLE BILLY
Justin Clark
HITLER WANTED WHITES ONLY FUCK OFF NAZI!
Racist go back to pol where you belong.
Not your America anymore whitoid.
Agreed, do it Uncle Billy!
Caleb Johnson
>HITLER WANTED WHITES ONLY FUCK OFF NAZI!
National Socialism can be appropriated by members of any ethnicity, in fact it already has been.
Nathan Garcia
Room temp IQ confirmed
Jordan Russell
Whites will burn for what they did regardless nazi shitlord. DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY, DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY, DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY, DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY!
Nathan Campbell
Why won't the Spaniards and Portuguese burn for what they did?
Brody Williams
>confederatecucks so btfo that they're sympathizing with Nazi's now
David Campbell
Spanish we're subjugated by whites, all of Europe was infested by whites just like America. Your grandchildren will be brown and you're people wiped out like the racists you are. I can't wait!
DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY!
Wyatt King
Sebastian Butler
>italians
>white
WEW
Dylan Taylor
Confederates are the same as nazis are the same as whites. None of them deserve to live peacefully. DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY!
Connor Anderson
Cuckfederates are so sad at this point theyr'e false flag posting to make themselves look justified.
Connor Brooks
Triggered shitskins
Hunter Gray
Italians all europeans are whites that don't deserve to exist any long. Go back to pol you neo nazi shitlord.
Jackson Morris
Fuck off stormfags, go back to pol where you belong.
Luis Johnson
Where is Spain and Portugal again?
>this fucking retard
Ryder Reyes
Fuck you cracker
Jacob Sullivan
Fuck you stormfag, go back to pol already and keep posting from mommys basement. Whites are all scum and your memes won't save you.
Jackson Jones
You mad nigger?
Noah Sanders
>memes won't save you
Hunter Ramirez
RIP discord fag
Aiden Morales
Fuck off stormfag back to pol where you belong, DO IT AGAIN DADDY SHERMAN, DO IT AGAIN DADDY SHERMAN! More dead whites the better.
Angel Ross
We shouldn't be surprised, losers tend to congregate.
It's our fault for not educating them and re-investing in their industry, good news is if we burn them again we won't have lost much.
Ian Harris
>whites are all scum
>t. Angry shitskin
Asher Rivera
Checked and kekked
Evan Long