Obviously B, or is it?

obviously B, or is it?

Attached: b.jpg (960x720, 152K)

I'd choose C, but that's because I'm a fag. Maybe A if I was drunk

Why the fuck should I give it to these little shits? I'm going to take it and stick it in my ass

If you pick anything other than B you're a commie pinko bastard

Give the flute to B, ask if she can let A play it every now and then and kick C down a flight of stairs for being a whiny, manipulative faggot.

big agree, i hate people like c

Child Three because I"m not a complete fucking retard like these blue pilled/virtual signaling normie faggots

Attached: 1530713095845.jpg (762x429, 68K)

B literally is communism
>workers deserve the fruits of their labor
>workers should own the products they produce
A is capitalism. C is socialism.

Why are you posting this again? lmao

If you pick A then you're retarded, she already knows how to play therefore she doesn't need it

If you choose B you're correct because she made it put in the work and now she needs to learn

If you choose C you're retarded and you're a weak empath.

Yes, it is obviously B. She made it so it's her flute and to take it from her would literally be stealing.

in this specific situation, B would be reasonable, sensible, and moral. However, abstracting this problem makes choice A more appealing. What's the point of putting such work and time into an object if it cannot be utilized to its fullest extent.

>no argument detected

I'd create 3 nonworking copies and sell one to each privately, and keep the original flute

That's a really good (((business))) idea there, user

B is not a worker. There's no third party who made a contract to pay B money and supply tools and materials in exchange for the completed flute.

realistically if anyone were to encounter this situation in real life they would give it back to B because they made it. However, since this entire exercise is really just a transparent way for manchildren to virtue signal their based and redpilled(tm) political beliefs, it doesn't really matter. All that matters is that I've chosen against the redistribution choice, making me the strongest, smartest, and most virile

Attached: 1543079776229.jpg (640x640, 75K)

its clearly B

Attached: Hammer_and_sickle_red_on_transparent.svg.png (200x200, 8K)

>B literally is communism
>C is socialism.
I don't think you know what these words mean.
there the same just on different levels.

so B is communism/socialism
and C is capitalist welfare

Attached: 1539292729552.png (431x311, 171K)

>third party who made a contract to pay B money and supply tools and materials in exchange for the completed flute

though a supper structure of coercion and violence. The contract is ethically unjustifiable. The flute makers should go on strike and demand better pay. NO, "WAGES ARE THEFT" they chant, all together they rise up and declare a flute makers republic. Where flutes are distributed my need. Where a man can build flutes for 4 hours a day 3 days a week. DOWN WITH CAPITALISTS, DOWN WITH BOSSES, TOGETHER WE STAND, FLUTES IN HAND AND BREAK THE CHAINS!!! WE LIVE ARE LIVE AS FREE MEN!!!!!

Attached: 1539294828768.png (1000x940, 393K)

No you are fucking retarded, if it was communism they would cut the flute in 3 pieces and give it to each kid. A is not capitalism either because Child A didn't fucking pay for the flute.

A is the pragmatic option

What is this gay shit. So plainly transparent. It is never going to convince someone to change their beliefs, it is literally just for the circle jerk. FUCK COMMIES right guys!

If it were communism, child B would have used wood and tools to make the flute that A and C have partial ownership of, so A and C would also have a partial right to the fruits of the flute.

How I see it:
A is communism (redistribution chosen to maximize the work force)
B is capitalism (individual property, owns choice of redistribution)
C is socialism (redistribution chosen to equalize individuals)

I'd give it to A just to be a dick to B and C

>A: play basic songs teacher taught her, either never advancing further and become a spoiled roast beef or make it into an orchestra performing beautiful soundtracks
>B: traditionalist enough to create own flute, will play real viking ass folk metal if decides to learn how to use, might get gored by wild boar
>C: practice day and nigt, either die of starvation or make it to perform proper funky ass folk blues on busy street to make money for family, sometimes playing in local bars
Your choice anons.

A is communism you stupid nigger
>to each according to his ability, to each according to his own

Child B, always.

Attached: 2731676 - The_Idea_of_Justice child_b literature.png (354x462, 25K)

child B decides what to do. She made it and she chooses who gets it

Maybe it's about ethics, rather than economics.

She certainly was correct when she said that she can't play it.

I give it to C because l hate women

Its obviously C. Anyone who chooses A or B is a double digit IQ fucking lunatic.

A can use her talent and raise funds to buy a flute.

B can just build her own flute. If she did it once she can do it again and she doesnt need two fucking flutes.

C needs the flute. Its all he fucking has. The other two can manage without the flute. Sorry for the f bombs but I really resonate with this kid and just fuck you if you chose anyone else than C. Fuck you.

>C
Beggar, gtfo
>B
Doesn't realize that after the product is finished it belongs to another individual, nobody cares about you, gtfo
>A
Truly correct

B made the flute with their own stuff. They're not a worker or anything. The "fruits of labor" part throws people off and make them think its socialist. If you baked a cake with your ingredients and hard work it shouldn't matter if you can eat it or not, that cake is yours.

Perhaps A or C could trade something for the flute to compensate B for the labour required to make it.

This seems fair.

Did child b make it on her own completely of her own volition and with her own resources? If so, it belongs to her.

Otherwise, it doesn't rightfully belong to anyone in the group of three. B is the most likely contender. But if she can't play the flute how the fuck did she make one?

im sure many flute manufacturers cant play, its basically just a metal tube with a bunch of holes and hinges

Attached: flute.jpg (1367x734, 43K)

Lol poorfag, get bent

theft is never justified. that's what C is. i grew up in the same position but id never forcibly take something from someone better off than me