Why don't we simply say Spanish is one language and Portuguese, Galician, Castilian and Catalan are dialects?

Galician is latin same as portuguese

Excellent, informative and hillarious post.

Spanish is just retarded italian

>american education

Attached: images (22).jpg (354x415, 23K)

Would you prefer "heavily latinized", autist?

Same as portuguese both latin dialects of uneducated people

thanks user, I thought so too

zitto animale

>le more people speak spansih so spanish must be the standard language and oldest langauge that all the other languages come from

stop assuming shit

>il calzoni italiani hablani la linguini heladini il portugini estupidini

No, you disgusting mutt. Galician shares no vocabulary with any romace language. It's an agglutinable language related to German.

are you mongoloid?

Attached: brainlet 2.png (406x438, 57K)

If neapolitan and venetian are dialects of the same language, moortuguese and castilian could perfectly be dialects aswell

(You)

Matate a ti, patínsos porcos, o teu tipo é unha peste sobre as Américas.

for sure you are drinking to much tequilla Juarez.

>Spanish
You mean Castilian?

No, I mean calling Castilian, Portuguese, etc. dialects of Spanish.

But “Spanish” in the modern day refers specifically to Castilian.

BUT I DON'T MEAN TO THE FUCKING MODERN DAY DAMN YOU HOLY SHIT FUCK FUCK FUCK I MEAN UNIFYNG ALL OF THEM UNDER THE NAME OF THE OLD PROVINCE OF HISPANIA FUCK FUCK I HATE YOU

cayese puto

Well, we all knew that the scottish people spoke many different languages.

Because they aren't variations of spanish, they are languages that came from the same iberian romance group spanish came from. Retard.

Because Portuguese, Galician and Catalan are more different to Castillian Spanish than Rioplatense Spanish is to Castillian Spanish, or Mexican Spanish is to Castillian Spanish and even Chilean Spanish is to Castillian Spanish.

but the Italian word "dialetto" has little different connotations than the Spanish "dialecto" or English "dialect"

That's what I mean

>Rioplatense Spanish is to Castillian Spanish, or Mexican Spanish is to Castillian Spanish and even Chilean Spanish is to Castillian Spanish.
Those are not dialects, just accents.

What's the difference between a language and a dialect?

No, what you basically said was
>Why aren't these different languages dialects of the same language?

It’s entirely political. Most linguists would say that Iberian “dialects” are distinct languages

That's dumb

Basque > Asspañol

Isn't Catalan more close to French than to Castillian?

because those languages have existed 1000 years and have evolved to develop clear distinctions
Spanish speakers can't understand spoken galician, catalán or portuguese most of the time
youtube.com/watch?v=CNU0t4-tFjw

>It's entirely political
Wrong. There's still significant linguistic differences even though the mutual intelligibility can be high.

> Chilean
> Spanish

Attached: nocountry_l.jpg (320x240, 20K)

All of those are clearly independent languages, other thing is if they are useless or not, which they are except portuguese maybe.

Galician co 100% latin you disgusting fuck, it is basque that is non indoeuropean.

But Catalan isn't an Ibero-Romance language. It's a Gallo-Romance language with Spanish influences, and it's actually more closely related to Occitan than Spanish.

ITT galicia is SUEBI

Attached: chrome_2018-04-18_00-11-05.png (222x175, 66K)

Attached: 1516303009863.jpg (600x470, 92K)

It confers nothing except uneducated speech.

That's unironically portoguese though

>be uneducated rural fucktard
>corrupt the pronounciations and spellings
Romance "languages"

Because Portuguese and Galician are older than Spanish.

Portugal is older than Spain by centuries.

Spanish is more proper latin than the n tier bunfuckery of portuguese/galician/catalan latin dialect.

>be uneducated rural fucktard
>corrupt the pronounciations and spellings
American "English"

Mental retardation.

Portuguese became an official written language in the 12th century. Spanish (Castilian) became an official language in the 13th century. So technically Portuguese came first.

Galicia is g*rm

Attached: DMcMcHKX0AcnibD.jpg (800x650, 90K)

And Spain didn't become a nation until the late 15th century. By then, Portugal already had 300 years of history as a country.

None are languages, they are uneducated speech of orcs, it was latin without education.

80 iq post.

Portuguese is terribly spoken and corrupted latin, the language was called latin.

Spanish is terribly spoken latin as is all Romance languages, the Hispanian regions dialects.

Attached: history-roman-spain.jpg (416x342, 29K)

Spain = Hispania
Portugal is spanish as is the former kingdom of castile, aragon, barcelonian counts, biscayan provinces, baetican provinces etc..

>Portugal is spanish
DELET

I don't see what is the issue, portugal is portuese and Spanish that is the state that portugsl got its language latin from.

Did Latin come from portugal?

>mutt understanding of linguistic

Attached: IMG_20180327_211004.jpg (271x364, 26K)

afaik portuguese kept most of the latin vowels while spanish due the iberian/basque influx only has five

>implying this isn't how every single language evolved
retard

Because luckily enough it's not up to monkeys such as yourself to decide. Now go back to eating bannanas and beheading other monkeys.

>evolved
Kek
Fuck off mentally retarded seperatist.

>stating facts means im separatist
what a delussional dumbfuck you are
im not even a separatist

Attached: 350px-Linguistic_map_Southwestern_Europe.gif (350x317, 135K)

I have no issue infering spsnish has no reason to exist and it is jyst corruoted latin what goes through to your mibd to make you think catalan, Portuguese, galician are not the same?

Nonsense propaganda of seperatists.
Post a few years back it will all be latin.

There is no reason for a castillian, galician, catalan, basque state should exist not united to another, that is not supporting further disunity and destruction of the state into cities.

>few years

CHI Guevara detected, everybody already spoke vulgar latin during roman times, classical latin was spoken by the elites

It wouldn't have been. Latin was dead by the time of Julius Caesar. Only the elite spoke Classical Latin (which even then is a degenerate version of Old Latin) but preferred to speak Greek. The masses only spoke Vulgar Latin, so by the time Portugal was colonised, all the settlers and administrators spoke Vulgar Latin. Thus Portuguese was never truly Latin.

i won't even bother witchu my nigga, you're dumb as a brick
basic linguistics and evolution is propaganda to you
latin people speak was way different than classical texts btw

Attached: 32%20Cordial%20cuatro%20postrimeras-Garcia%20Santamaria-Hurus-Incunables%20Libros%20Antiguos-libro%2 (1000x700, 422K)

What happened to your regionalist seperatist propaganda of "catalan" nation?

Fuck off retard die subversive traitor.

Spain is a single people and a single state.

its impossible to use logic with americans
all they think about is politics and their ideologies, they can't adapt their brains to facts

Die trash.

ITT : mutts cannot understand linguistic evolutions

The Spanish nation and people will not disintegrate and be disunited, they are one people.

Nafri

>sandniggerish muttlard

Barely human anymore

Dunno what the fuck you are talking about, CHI

>sandnigger
Im not a nigger like you mohammad.

Attached: Screenshot_2018-02-23-18-23-37.png (720x1280, 797K)

>people of catalonia dudnt speak catalan
>catalan is the nation of catalonia

Es el subhumANO mestizo

Seperatism in spain should be illegal, and all regionalist party members jailed for treason.

Yes you are Mahmud al burgeristani
Now shut your shitskin mouth

And mestizos like you should be castrated. But such is life, mi amigo tiraflechas

Ah, I have looked passed your sunhumanity bait, Spanish people are a single people, the Spanish state will not be destroyed by traitors enemies of the state.

Attached: 1526259421962.png (420x591, 21K)

You should be lynched.

Because Spanish was never historically spoken in Galicia, Portugal or Catalonia