I’ve been studying kanji through Genki till very recently (now I use KKLC) and just memorized the sounds of the kanji and not whether they’re onyomi or kunyomi. I know which to use purely from experience, but doing just that mostly works. Is this a bad approach in the long term?
Jaxon Long
I think it will be sorted out by itself when you achieve to build knowledge of a thousand of kanjis, as on-yomi have peculiar trait. In short, they sound really like chinese whereas kun-yomi sound really Japanese.
Is KKLC a good replacement for RTK? Also, is dedicated Kanji worth doing instead of vocabulary with kanji?
Henry Young
I haven’t used RTK, but KKLC seems like a direct successor to it. It still has stories, meanings, and an emphasis on learning simpler graphemes to build up to complex kanji, but it also lets you associate each kanji with a word or two, continues with stories throughout, and doesn’t leave you not actually knowing the usage or reading of anything. But you can’t really use the “rush all the kanji in a few months and learn them for real later” approach; it’s a long-term commitment.
Nicholas Bell
I have a couple of questions...
1) I'm going through Core 6000 and I'm finding some verbs that have the same root but different suffixes, like 浮く・浮かぶ・浮かべる or 済む・済ます・済ませる. Where do you have to use which? Is there a rule?
2) I was reading some comments about how a manga wouldn't continue on the west because of some sort of sexual scandal (Rurouni Kenshin IIRC) and one of them said "まんがーか変態にぅだ際". Did the guy writing it have some sort of stroke at the end or is it slang or something, never seen that before.
Gavin Gutierrez
Nothing rushed about learning all 3000 kanji in only 150 days and then keep on reviewing for the rest of your life.
>is dedicated Kanji worth doing instead of vocabulary with kanji Depends. Learning vocab will give you immediate gratification and you will be able to read/consume Japanese faster.
Learning kanji will give you a solid foundation, but eat away hundreds of hours. Learning vocab will be way easier after that, but until you start doing it, all the studied kanji will be nothing but stories and scribbles, not even readings to comfort you.
In general I'd say go for kanji study if you have the time and patience to spare, and even so, you can do vocabulary recognition study on the side, it all boils down to whether you have time for it or not.
Ryan Phillips
>浮く・浮かぶ it's a bit of a difference between float to the surface and a cloud floating in the air the rest will make more sense to you when you've gotten a bit more into grammar
James Myers
1) Check if they are transitive or intransitive. 付く is intransitive 付ける is transitive
First one is "to be attached", the subject will suffer the action of being sticked. Second one is "to attach", so the subject will perform the action of sticking another thing onto something.
There are verb pairs like this in English/Spanish as well, for instance: Stop. It can both mean to interrupt someone or to be interrupted.
But for most cases you will have to think about it as a verb modified to be intransitive: To eat and "to be eaten".
Also not all verbs have pairs, and there might be more than 2, so don't try to force them into a formula before you're used enough to their presence.
2) No idea.
Chase Thompson
I was thinking about dedicated Kanji when I get further along with reading as a side thing. Doing some 2k6k as I work through Japanese the Manga Way until then. That already takes up a decent chunk of my day.
>back to fluently doing my reps without ぐずぐずing Seems like breaks are a good idea from time to time, who knew!
>新しい仕事の提供をくられました or >仕事の新しい提供をくられました ?
Lincoln Jones
Don't have Anki on my work computer, so had to dig through some photos online for my grid from a few days ago. I like gaining "knowledge" on my lunch breaks.
Henry Harris
I'd would be 新しい仕事 but I don't think they use 新しい仕事の提供 anyway and use 受ける for receive, you're thinking about it a bit too literally
Adam Cox
Thanks, I guess I should've made the question more generalized/detailed. It's about the order of adjectives, if you've got multiple no/na/i adjectives, do they have a specific (attributive) order they have to be in?
there are no "no adjectives" per se... they get translated that way, but I wouldn't call them that, because it just causes needless confusion anyway, for example you'd say 永遠の青い空 and not 青い永遠の空
Robert Cox
How much Japanese (reading/listening) can I learn in 6 months if I dedicate 1-3 hours a day? I'm by no means a genius but I did make it through engineering school
Noah Garcia
Are you a total beginner?
Cooper Fisher
Yes. No Japanese knowledge outside of itadakimasu and arigatou
Jose Phillips
Genius has nothing to do with it. Persistence (and ideally experience with learning a foreign language) is what matters.
6 * 30 * 1 | 3 = 180 to 540 hours. That's probably enough to pass N5 (according to the JLEC itself):
>N5 (no prior kanji knowledge) 325–600 hours >The ability to understand some basic Japanese. >Reading >One is able to read and understand typical expressions and sentences written in hiragana, katakana, and basic kanji. >Listening >One is able to listen and comprehend conversations about topics regularly encountered in daily life and classroom situations, and is able to pick up necessary information from short conversations spoken slowly.
Jordan Anderson
Definitely at least N5, closer to N4 if you’re learning effectively.
Easton Diaz
you could pursue the act of making sense of letters and symbols to a greater extent than you are doing at the present moment
STEMfags are usually really bad at learning languages though, lel
>inb4 but muh programming skills
Nathan Martin
>if it still exists god I hope not one of the few times when I was checking it out it only had some kind of furry and some other autist shitposting about whatever kind of shit, certainly not japanese though
Austin Gomez
Are there any good apps for learning? Duolingo isn't doing it for me.
Tyler Perez
Lingodeer is basically Duolingo but actually built for Asian languages. It actually teaches you concepts before you start each lesson.
PAIR it with Anki for vocabulary and it's a solid start. It is a little slow less detailed, so you'll probably want a good grammar guide as well.
Easton Murphy
What does adding 通し to the stem of a verb do? Context:
>歩き通しだったので、日が沈む頃になるとお腹が減り始めました。 I understand everything but the 通し
Bentley Miller
It's not really /djt/ by ethos anymore. a lot of people outside the threads here got invited and it became a more general Japanese learning channel (or at least tried to be before I left).
Sebastian Flores
Google is your friend. (造)《動詞の連用形に付いて、「どおし」の形で》その動作・状態がずっと続いている意を表す。「座り─・働き─・負け─」
Landon Rogers
I know you wanted to jump on the chance to use the google it meme but dont you think I tried already? If Im this far into the language then obviously I can use google. Explain it in English or just ignore the question, Ill just have to look up more and more shit and go down a rabbit hole for one fucking thing.
Nathaniel Roberts
Sorry. I assumed you'd understand the definition itself if you had no problems with the rest of the sentence you posted. It pretty much emphasizes the state of the verb (stem) as continuing for a long time. The translation would probably be (how I see it) as: >Since I've been walking all this time, by the time the sun began setting I started to feel hungry.
Cameron Young
>It's not really /djt/ by ethos anymore okay but can you please post an invite if you have access?
Matthew Sullivan
Sorry I had a bad rundown with someone yesterday and you got caught in crossfire.
Jonathan Clark
Great app thanks
Ryder Bennett
Just remember that it won't teach you more than the first-month basics. Apps can only be supplements to your real study.
Blake Butler
This book works pretty well with Lingodeer I've found.
I want to spend a shit ton of time studying for the summer
maybe the solution is to cut off shitposting entirely
Jordan James
Watch anime while shitposting
Daniel Thomas
The solution is to read like a motherfucker
Adam King
Listening to Japanese audio while sleeping doesn't count as subconscious input for AJATT, right? I haven't started AJATT yet, was just wondering
Joshua Gray
There is some paper around that talks about how passive listening right after falling asleep is effective. But I think that one was about retaining new words not learning new ones.
Jordan Clark
this is such a stupid meme for lazy people who want to "learn" but not do anything for it
Juan Gomez
Why are you so sure that it's a stupid meme?
Jason Edwards
A lot of people just enjoy the idea of learning a language without actually putting any effort into it. If you aren't jumping into native content within three months of learning you probably fall into this category.
Jordan Hill
the only thing you'll achieve is bad sleep and a weird craving for sushi
Nicholas King
支援上げ
Justin Roberts
i think i'm learning more from reading than anki, i guess it's more natural
Proof read for me please. My Japanese is horrible and this is first time I try to write it. Also maybe answer my questions. I did use google translate for some of the vocabulary and it took me like fifteen minutes to write.
>夜私は河原町へいきました。 good, but you might as well insert "、" between 夜 and 私 >何も買いませんでしたでも、雰囲気を楽しました。 何も買いませんでした「が」、雰囲気を楽し「み」ました。 楽しむ enjoy >可愛くて独身くな女の子を数えしました。 独身 sounds like "bachelor", simply replace it with "彼氏のいない" . also 数えしました makes no sense to me. >二人です。 二人だけでした。 >河原町に可愛くて独身な女の子がありませんと思うします。 河原町に可愛くて彼氏のいない女の子はいないと思います。 >日本に可愛いくて引っ込み思案くな女の子はどこですか。助けてください。 可愛くて引っ込み思案な女の子は日本のどこにいますか。
Brody Morales
In my opinion, the only books you really need at that point is the A Dictionary of Japanese Grammar series.
Wyatt Cook
Hey, you may have already seen this but in case you didn't I made a big retimed anime subtitle pack. You may find it useful.
Daniel Green
I'm not sure if I'll ever put it to good use, but thanks
Tuned into Fuji TV yesterday and there was a segment with an old Japanese man, a dog, and drugs (something crystalline). I don't know enough Japanese to understand everything, but they seemed to heavily imply drugs were put into the dog somehow and the old man may have been involved. Does anyone know what this story was talking about or have a link to a write up so I can figure it out myself?
Levi Williams
I just wanted a subtitle pack for Detective Conan...