Well?

>left
Instant gratification for low-life degenerates. A fleeting moment of post-ejaculatory happiness followed by a state of anhedonia. You will forget the image by tomorrow.
>right
Profound and sublime, akin to standing on top of mountains and looking down into the vast valleys that incite a feeling of weltschmerz. The colour combination speaks to the human soul, and encourages the progress of society. This image will be remembered throughout generations.

if you don't like rothko but you like anime i unironically, like not even memeing, think you need to be executed

The artist on the right is so much more talented than the random one on the left he can allow himself to draw cubes.

Based

I hate both

Right.

Attached: 1437372542757.jpg (930x859, 58K)

Right

my fav painting is this tho

Attached: dresden-bombing-1945-002.jpg (1033x727, 204K)

>artistic talent
>left
>artistic "merit"
right

>Hitler
>Guy who couldn't grasp perspective

Left is derivative with no individual expression or style. Just making the same thing everyone else does, drawing on model isn't all that impressive
Right is the perfection of simplified expressionism
You tell me

you're telling this to a board of neckbeards who don't go outside and whose idea of doing something "exotic" is putting something other than ketchup on their hamburgers

then when you let them know they're cultureless retards they'll get mad at you and spam smug anime girl faces or some faggot nerd shit

Right
Left is illustration, not art

>Posts guy who could only paint meh tier landscapes
>Hated the Poles who made objectively better art
Really makes you think

Attached: 9iNdYSJ.jpg (1404x1774, 498K)

'perfection of simplified expressionism' is a periphrasis for turd.

based and thispilled

Right.

Attached: npcjak.jpg (1000x1000, 46K)

I thought Bazinga was Russian?

left has technique/skill but no artistic talent

right has neither

BASED

Attached: Karen do it again.png (800x1785, 1.72M)

I don't pick one because it's a retarded comparison

>left
makes my dick hard
>right
doesn't

as simple as that, really.

Attached: shrug.jpg (554x439, 31K)

Attached: hahadestruction.gif (700x393, 737K)

Obviously left. Modern art is trash and if you think Rothko isn't a hack you're a moron.

Attached: 1483169729927.jpg (498x498, 45K)

do it again Bomber Harris

Attached: Lancaster.jpg (1920x1080, 300K)

Anime is not, and will never be art. Death to anime.

Attached: f5oSgGD.png (960x540, 860K)

Right.
The whole anime industry combined has less artistic talent than a braindead paralysed monkey

based and redpilled

Left, could easily do right but it would take years of practice to do left.

Right, obviously. Though a small picture won't do it justice. The wank pic fills it purpose even this small, so you could argue that it works better in this context.

DO

Art is a meme and painting is the most pretentious discipline there is so left.

art is such a subjective and abstract concept at this point who gives a shit

is it really so hard to understand that different art movements and styles can be appreciated for different aspects and aren't meant to be viewed in the same way. The difference between say Picasso and Sargent is like chocolate cake and sushi. Also anime isn't art

Attached: pepe-is-caught-in-the-center-of-a-political-debate.jpg (1267x887, 103K)

>left is much more detailed so it's better
you're on Jow Forums, if you still can't figure out why that's fucking retarded you need to go back.

Dumb frogposter.

art is not defined merely on merit

How about you explain why three shitty lines a baby could do are better, or better yet, define what art even means.

Attached: 1539188456976.jpg (543x577, 123K)

dumb anime poster

Anime is Jow Forums, reddit frog belongs in reddit.

long live novorossia chan

Just look at the garbage on the right of OPs pic, it doesn't grasp nothing.

you don't look smart. you look like a fucking dumbass that got duped.

Thanks for the (You), kid. I know acting all tough and contrarian looks really mature in your underdeveloped brain, but once you get past the puberty you might start to actually think stuff trough.

>You see, whether you can draw like this or not, being able to think up this kind of design, it depends on whether or not you can say to yourself, ‘Oh, yeah, girls like this exist in real life. If you don’t spend time watching real people, you can’t do this, because you’ve never seen it. Some people spend their lives interested only in themselves. Almost all Japanese animation is produced with hardly any basis taken from observing real people, you know. It’s produced by humans who can’t stand looking at other humans. And that’s why the industry is full of otaku!

Attached: anime was a mistake.gif (410x230, 1.81M)

I hate modern art and I still prefer the right to fucking anime

Based

artist is homunculus
tsumino.com/Book/Info/35514/love-knot-tale-fakku

this tbqh

what's artist merit?

Cringe. You clearly don't understand art.

Miyazaki is a hack

>anime is professional art
Oh my god, so you're telling me all the users from DeviantArt, Tumblr, Facebook and even Jow Forums are the best artists ever? No way!

Beksinski was pole.

ad hominem argument here, but miyazaki probably has over forty thousand hours clocked in his craft (maybe like eighty thousand because of his inhuman work ethic) and what are you? a shitposter on a balkanized international Korean pop-idol discussion board who's never indirectly spoken to millions of people by creating a work of art, that's who

Trips>Dubs
Miyazaki confirmed hack

wtf I love makoto shinkai now

Left

while the art on the left isn't anything amazing its at least something beyond what a layman like me could create.
The 'art' on the right looks like it was made by a kid with a box of crayons.

Art has to have some kind of substance in both its technique and its 'meaning' The one on the left has at the very minimum a bit of both, the one on the right has neither.

>inb4 muhh muh abstract meaning

abstract =/= meaningless color mess

>abstract =/= meaningless color mess

>Abstract thinking is critical for normal development, and exclusively concrete thinking can severely inhibit a person’s ability to learn, empathize, and relate to other people. The development of a theory of mind–the ability to place oneself in another’s shoes and guess what they are thinking or what it is like to be them–is key for developing strong social skills.
>The inability to think abstractly can be symptomatic of developmental delays. Children on the autism spectrum frequently struggle with abstract thinking, and may have difficulty with empathy and understanding others’ emotions. Head injuries and brain damage can also interfere with an individual’s ability to grasp abstract thoughts
Well that solves that

you'll realize how stupid you sound if you ever see a rothko in person

>the only brainlets ITT so far that argue left > right have been exclusively Americans
rmyt

Attached: 1537444405087.jpg (419x420, 28K)

Did you mean to reply to me? You're right
Abstract =/= meaningless color mess

Why post the definition?

>picking left over right means you must be a raging weeaboo America.

>It couldn't be that the left looks like it took at least more than half an hour to make, while the right looks like a orange and black crayon scribble.

It's almost like people think being contrarian and smug is some how smart, especially when it means poking fun at a country this board is obsessed with.

Attached: 1527524639958.png (800x450, 366K)

I'm making an implication. I know it's hard for your autistic mind to understand, but you seem to only be capable of concrete thinking.
Maybe try reading the post again because you're only proving me right

>I can't understand minimalism

Attached: IMG_0704.png (299x168, 11K)

thread
lmao who gives 1 shit about something like artistic merit, I'm not an artist, so what would I learn from a picture
right is absolutely meaningless though, it speaks nothing, it tells nothing, you are only defending it bc you are worthless as a person and want to gain the gratification of being a cultured person
basically, just kys trash pseud

dude so deep bruh like wtf dude crazy yoo yo dude ure crazy so deeep

>Let me just say something smug, then spend the next 90% of this sentience all of the bad words I heard my moms boyfriend say.

I was specifically implying that in order to say your art has some abstract meaning behind it, it has to be intended. You can't just draw a orange smudge and then later say.

>"Oh, it means [Art history 101 buzzword]"

and expect it to be taken seriously by anyone other than middle class yuppies and self congratulatory community college professors.

Does seeing some kike's inhuman snout will change someone's mind, no.

Fudging this.

>HUE makes funni joo meme

Isn't your cunt in the process of electing a literal dictator to be?

Thats not what art is about you neanderthal

i could take a hot dump on the carpet and it would have more "artistic merit" than an*Me

And Rothko created his art with the intent of expression his emotions
It's not meaningless, you're just too simple minded to realize it

jews are a retarded meme.

>you're just too simple minded to realize it
It's like you people can't listen to your embarrassing shit.

>he fell for the modern art is shit meme

The left indicates more skill, but the right indicates better aesthetic appreciation

Both are mediocre though

Pulling a literal
>Its 2 deep 4 yahou

You need to be at least 18 years old to post here.

an image of dog feces has more artist merit than weeb shit

this

...

left is art. right is not. not even about anime. the right one depicts nothing. it incapable of carrying meaning. its not even pretty. not even some intricate shape. it looks like a dirty smudge.

>Me no like thing, thing is worse than poopoo xd

You don't have to love, or even like weebshit in order to admit the one on the left had more effort, talent, and a bit of passion compared to the crayon smudge on the right.

Ignoring all of that, at the very minimum left took more than 5 seconds, a MS paint crayon tool, and a meme degree to make.

Attached: 1528222528559.jpg (687x778, 93K)

How sad and crude for men to declare war not only on an abstraction created by culture, but also on desire and pleasure.

and before anyone says anything about about artist intentions or anything. does the right picture make you feel anything? lets be honest no it doesnt. if you are really fucking high you might be able to interpret aka make up all kind of shit.

This.

There is a difference between making a piece of art with a specific abstract style, with the intention of not only showing your own meaning but creating the opportunity for others to get their own meaning out of your creation too. On top of this while doing it with hard artistic skill and technique.

vs

Making an orange smudge and, once you're done saying "This has a very deep meaning, because its abstract"

Its like when a kid imitates something he like or thinks is 'cool with out even understanding what he is missing. He'll make a crude recreating, and then spout all of the big words he learned.

A bunch of monkeys with time and tools could also make left at random. At some absurdly large number of monkeys and tools, it will also only take them five seconds. Now your metric of left and right is no longer talent and effort and passion, but gazillions of monkeys and crayons.

What now?

Attached: smug tsunemori.png (712x585, 438K)

what do you mean what now? the number of monkeys required to create a picture that resembles the left one is clearly much higher. that makes it objectivly better on the monkey index.

Clearly we use monkeycrayon as the official unit of artistic merit, defined by how many monkeys and crayons it takes to make a piece of art in five seconds. Left takes 10^1000000000000 monkeycrayons to make so it's better. Checkmate atheists

Attached: 1489632596846.jpg (499x499, 130K)