Vat grown muscle suits are a radical concept but are a more realistic powered armor concept than atomic backpacks. Lets fite!
Calorie tech is more advanced than battery tech. We have the ability to grow any type of cell on 3d printed scaffolding into any form or function. (Muscle, bone even working livers) We have interface tech from the prosthetics world that can take direction straight from our nerves, even brainwaves. We have the tech to simulate every magor organ function artificially.
A supersoldier will put on an extra 300 lbs of pure muscle, wrapped around a sealed hardsuit. The hardsuit keeps the soldier from being crushed by the muscles, manages environment, connection and vitals. The muscle suit can now wear its own custom armor. Its requires concentrated nutrient packs, massage therapy, electro stim training and dialysis to function. No roid rage supersoldiers on leave the beast stays at base.
To add to this your not limited to human dna. A 90lbs chimp has enough strength to rip a mans arm off. Electrically controlled muscles can go from zero to tard strength on demand. The muscle groups can be modular for quick replacement so you can send chunks of it to recover or throw it in the soup.
How would Jow Forums Frankenstein/ Dr. Moreau up a hulk suit?
Human muscle one it's own is capable of a lot more than it's given credit, it just has that built in safety switch so we don't destroy our joints .
Anyway, how do you plan to manage heat
Eli Gray
Hard shell space suit style. Keeps you comfy while floating in meat and not crushed by a spasm. So... swimmin in piss?
Dominic Morgan
So instead of just building powered armour you build a muscle suit and put powered armour under it anyways? Seems dumb as fuck.
Jack Sanders
I imagine it wouldn't be motorized. Just something to provide a shell, likely an ultra-light and rigid material.
Nicholas Miller
The power is from the muscles. The vat grown muscles the whole thread is about. Like I said the innersuit is to keep you from being squeezed, connected to the system and comfy.
Ayden Johnson
building your suit out of muscle don't alleviate the need for a power supply. You need a stomach and shit. It needs food.
"Let's make an exoskeleton out of meat" isn't a gamechanger.
Jonathan Parker
Yup. Like I said all organs can be artificially produce now a days. Nutrient concentrait instead of batteries a dyalisis machine instead of kidneys. Half the need organs can be waiting at a maintenance bay.
Austin Fisher
>Like I said all organs can be artificially produce now a days.
No, they can't, and if I'm wrong I would ask you to prove your bullshit claim with an actual piece of scientific literature and not an infowars link.
Carter Myers
Seems to me like a body that huge would require a ton of food to keep going, and if it gets shot through the heart it would rot pretty fast and be unsalvageable.
Alexander Flores
>muscle don't alleviate the need for a power supply I actually think he might be on to something. Batteries are just too heavy. And human bodies can go days without food and still be combat effective. I imagine a purpose built "exo-body" could potentially be stronger and more efficient.
Owen Edwards
why not just genetically alter fat people?
Ryan Sullivan
What year are you typing from? Its called life support and yes there is an artificial replacement for every major organ. Thats with machines not talking about vat grown stiff. Nutrient delivery, electro manipulation and toxin removal have been a thing for a minute or two.
That's like calling the wiring in my house a "working nervous system".
Alexander Morgan
lol no it's not, not even OP but that's a garbage strawman.
Benjamin Wilson
Muscles have the distinct advantage of being able to use glucose/atp for fuel rather than shitty li-po batteries. A human can work all day on just the amount of fuel in a couple of meals.
Muscles are literally super advanced nanotech that converts chemical energy into mechanical force on the molecular level.
Lucas Jenkins
>building your suit out of muscle don't alleviate the need for a power supply. You don't need an external power supply, idiot. Where are your 80lbs of batteries to keep you moving through the day? >stomach and shit Used to process raw materials into fuel, and still much more mass-efficient than banks of batteries.
You could just lug around a bucket of sugar (which has many times the energy density of rechargable batteries) and a small biochemical plant on your back made specifically to power your exoskeleton. This is actually really clever.
Brayden Myers
Other than contrarian bantz. Whats the hurdle you see here. I aint a scientist just a dude what binged ted talks n shit and lurks mech threads.
My theory here is based on what I see happing. Proved working tech. None of that well if the battery tech matures or if only we had battletech nano quantum shit. Then Im putting it together like lego.
Joshua Hughes
Chimp muscles are largely incapable of the fine motor skills that we are. They're either relaxed or in use, 0 or 100%sort of thing.
Jeremiah Brooks
There is no hurdle that user is just a moron. But R&D takes a lot of time and money so you're not gonna see anything like it anytime soon. Even if the concept is solid, the execution can prove difficult or impossible - hence why engineers exist.
Samuel Gonzalez
>nano quantum shit What do you think muscles are, exactly?
Luke Perez
That's bullshit. They might have less fine motor control due to different wiring, but pretty much every animal has fine motor control. You literally cannot function without it.
Daniel Morgan
the nice thing about this concept is you could make them with tons of redundant vital systems. Multiple hearts, a circulatory system that automatically and rapidly clots / restricts itself if it is severed in a critical area, biological auto injectors that contain chemicals to counteract things like nerve agents etc etc. It could be supplied with extremely efficient food too as you could precision tailor the "digestive" system of the unit to work with a specific food source as efficiently as possible. The problem is the massive insane amount of research and development that would go into making this even remotely doable.
I was talking out my ass but I was right: >Walker's hypothesis stems partly from a finding by primatologist Ann MacLarnon. MacLarnon showed that, relative to body mass, chimps have much less grey matter in their spinal cords than humans have. Spinal grey matter contains large numbers of motor neurons—nerves cells that connect to muscle fibers and regulate muscle movement. >More grey matter in humans means more motor neurons, Walker proposes. And having more motor neurons means more muscle control. sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/03/090330200829.htm
It's a wiring thing.
Andrew Ward
ALS isn't an organ you fucking idiot. Stop talking if you don't know what the fuck you're talking about.
Lincoln Flores
So the worst kind of bantz. You would have been fun in the old sealand threads. I even misspelled words for cretins to fixate on for bumps and you go with this? Whatever gets you through you're day. nofun.gif
Oliver Thompson
adding onto how insane the r&d would have to be for this, I honestly think the level of understanding and ability to manipulate biology to make a project like this work would mean by the time we are able to do something like this we will also be able to make humans biologically immortal. Thats how far off we are from being able to do this on this level, Growing individual organs is a far cry from being able to build something like this from the ground up, putting it all together and having it work.
Michael Morgan
>I even misspelled words for cretins to fixate on Imagine if this was you.
Kevin Adams
>we will also be able to make humans biologically immortal. Thats how far off we are We're within a couple generations. We're on the brink of "curing" cancer with genetically modified t-cells. Gene therapy is entering the fore. It's happening lads.
Adam Scott
this is fucking intense user, can we really control shit with brainwaves? I had no idea.
Dominic Bailey
I work with Joe Friaetta/Novartis at Penn ITMAT on Adenoviridae stuff for CAR-T cells, you couldn't be more wrong.
Blake Morgan
Apparently NPR lied to me. I hope you feel good for shooting me down. :'(
Colton Lopez
Well yeah. Thats old tech. With out implants the latency isnt at realtime speeds last I checked +/-600 ns lag. But you dig into the prosthetic world with the implants available it gets real doable. The newest and best gives two way feedback. Yes thats right fake legs that move when you think, with a sense of touch. Spooky times. youtu.be/CDsNZJTWw0w
Liam Smith
CAR-Ts are promising stuff, but much like CRISPR people on the internet/news-types who have no real understanding of it are lauding it as something it's not. There are still a lot of problems with how it's done right now. It's going places, but immune-modulation is a long way off from being reliable, consistent, widely-applicable, and scalable.
If you're ever in the Philly area though you should Joe talk sometime. He blew the fucking roof off Drexel last week, standing room only.
Eli James
So what OP is saying is that we should build EVA unit meat robots?
This is an interesting concept. You could.get away with less organs than an actual body, leaving space for the guy inside.
You could ditch the digestive system entirely and just have a concentrated glucose and nutrient solution pumped into the bloodstream. You'd need lungs though, big ones, to supply all the oxygen. You'd need kidneys and a liver too, so quite a lot of organs to fit in.
Major issues:
>Needs armour, meat is rather vulnerable to bullets. >Cooling system for all the muscles. Sweat would only be effective if there was a lot of exposed skin, which you cant have. You could distribute lungs through the suit with many breathing orifices to allow it to pant.
Owen Evans
>get new bio arms that have gorilla strength >*spine breaks*
Benjamin Torres
Just build it like an exoskeleton from the ground up >bones Use the internal structure as support >lungs I'm sure we can figure out how to build an artificial lung. Bonus points for turbocharging it. >kidneys livers You could probably build a single armored box to contain all the biochemical reprocessing plants aka organs >cooling Run the blood through radiators.
The idea is actually pretty ebin. It could solve the battery problem and the electric-joint-servos-are-single-points-of-failure problem.
Jonathan Price
>armor plated meat suits that run of digested matter I'm intrigued and frightened
Gavin Anderson
Imagine the final layer before armor and EQ is a skin layer of rhino hide. Maybe some scales.
Samuel Adams
Well obviously you'd also get a reinforced gorilla and everything else to handle the strength user. You dont want to lift something heavy with ease and then have your legs snap off at the knees.
Elijah Morris
>OGUS
>The OGUS has become an indispensible asset to the military forces of all Category 1 nations. A hybrid of mechanical parts and specially tailored, silicone based organic components, the OGUS series have achieved a battlefield capability superior to anything a conventional human soldier could match. Expensive initially, maintenance is actually quite simple: the OGUS series is primarily self healing and is powered by methane created by the processing of organic matter (it eats meat.)
>Key Features- >-Mortar used for bunker penetration and indirect fire roles. >-Human-like limbs allow for use of aquired enemy weaponry when deployed behind enemy lines and supply sources are cut off. >-Long, thin, and highly flexible neck allow for excellent scope and visibility. >-Small profile presents the smallest possible target while OGUS observation is maintained. >-Modular load bearing packs on upper thighs for equipment.
I think you're underestimating how inefficient artificial organs would be compared to real ones. If you want to fit a liver, kidneys and lungs into the smallest box possible the artificial versions would be much larger, and will need a seperate power supply. Whats the point of burning glucose in muscle fibres if you need to battery pack for your artificial kidneys? Might as well just pump blood a little further.
I think electronics would be most useful in advanced sensors and muscle control
Jonathan Campbell
Looks neat.
Sounds kinda dorky, but neat nontheless.
Levi Jones
Cool concept user, but a few problems come to mind. I won't go into the details of how we don't yet have the ability to make huge cats of muscle organized into functional muscle groups, because we'll get there eventually. Stem cell differentiations are difficult and costly, ask me how I know.
The problems that come to mind are:
>respiration Notice the biggest limit to muscle function is actually them beginning to burn or give out. This is because they don't get enough O2 to respire, resorting to fermentation which builds up lactic acid. You would need a huge amount set of mechanical or biological lungs to get enough O2 exchange to prevent the muscles from burning out. This leads into the next big problem
>Fluid exchange You would need a huge amount of fluid/blood that contains hemoglobins or some artificial O2 binding compound that releases appropriately into the tissue. More expense and weight to provide function O2 exchange as well as dripping in sugar or other nutrients as fuel.
>Heat management All that giant muscle working hard requires heat to be managed before the tissue is damaged. This would mean skin that sweats or some sort of wicking cooling membrane. Means more water consumption/energy to manage the waste heat.
>Everything must be sterile Unless you put a functioning immune system in the meat somehow, which would be even more expense and another step closer to a full body system. Otherwise, the meat would be quickly infected by bacteria and viruses and start to rot and break down.
All these concerns and their solution lead to this.
>Weakness Your suit now has lungs that can be punctured, it can bleed out and become useless, can be infected and rot, it can work too hard and overheat and shut down.
Overall, the benefits in my opinion cannot sufficiently outweigh the benefits.
>Originally planned as a somewhat philanthropically oriented project intended to curb widespread corporate use of third world labour and sweatshop type practices. Mounted in a mechanical frame, genetically cultured “high wear” parts are grown in vats and regularly replaced. Not only are the meat components incredibly cheap to fashion and replace, they are extremely dextrous and efficient.
>Key Features- >-Four eyes used by CPU to coordinate assembly and work processes. >-Hazard pattern to alert human workers. >-Nutrient cocktails and preservatives pumped into organic parts to prevent rot and rigor mortis. >-The feet are toughened, and mechanically reinforced. While extremely nimble, these meat feet often need to be replaced daily. >-Docking bay connects worker to recharge stations and assorted heavy machinery. >-Reactor core encased in a thick sphere of titanium alloys to prevent explosions or leaks possibly incurred during serious accidents.
I like you. In my mind its mostly solved with tubes and bags. Small bagged bundles of muscle making big bags. This keeps it seperate limiting exposure, even to itself. Unlike a standard body. Mechanically attached in motion groups for swappability. Custom seperate arteries made to handle saline/brine antifreeze for multiple mechanical radiators. Which come spooky small now. O2 can be delivered via concentrate. Filtered and compressed for later. Its not digesting or thinking and rests like a zen monk. Computer aided motion control makes it move with little wasted effort. Demand may not be that high all the time. Tear me a new one?
Cameron Thomas
Cats can drink salt water. Perhaps that could be included at least.
Carson Evans
What kind of work are these fuckers doing that their feet need to be replaced DAILY
Gabriel Hill
The kind of work where you can afford to have a functioning nuclear reactor instead of a battery for every slave, but you can't afford to buy them shoes.
The artist is good at drawing but very dumb.
Evan Nelson
This is all fine and dandy, but how does it help with my dream of ultimately becoming a cute loli oper8tor?
Perhaps being nimble is the more important quality? Like you said, if you're at the level of affording a nuclear reactor for menial laborers, you can afford daily replacement of feet.
Sebastian Smith
I would also postulate the organic materials are 100% recyclable. You just need the time and space to grow them. If you factor in practically unlimited energy sources, and considering you can literally grow organic lifeforms out of dirt, it sounds pretty resource efficient to me.
Jonathan Hernandez
Learning how to mesh the human neural system to machinery is a necessary science to put your brain in a new body or control a separate body remotely. It is important.
Jack Nelson
I have five dollars I would like to donate to this very worthy cause.
Interesting idea, but our technology is even further from making this work than mechanical hardsuits. PS: The secret for mechanical hardsuits is turbine powerplants operating at excess of 20k RPMs, if not full on fuel cells.
Grayson Ramirez
A few days without food and a human isn't generally very functional because it's having to break down fat and muscle for energy.