Remington M8 or Winchester M1907?

Remington M8 or Winchester M1907?

Attached: RM8 & WM1907.jpg (1200x431, 47K)

I've got an 81 and I like it. Long recoil punches hard, though.

Remington, m8

So Remington M8? No contender from the Winchester?

You can clear a jam with a M8, something the Winchester can't do.

Winchester is much, much simpler, and more reliable. Even if it's a pain in the ass to manipulate because the recoil spring is stiff as fuck and the cocking handle is retarded.

They're close contenders, but I'd go with the M8 on aesthetics, charging handle, and muh AK safety

Remington m8

I had a chance to buy a M1907 a few months back. Regret not doing it

Bump

I vote 1907 but both are breddy neat

How hard the recoil compared to standard shotgun?

Fairly comparable, but sharper. You've got the entire bolt AND barrel recoiling together.

Attached: R81dump2.webm (800x450, 2.18M)

I have a 1907 and while it's a cool gun, it kicks harder than you expect and ammo is impossible to find or reload for. Dirt simple gun though, and probably the most advanced small arm that existed until the MP18. That said I'd much rather have a Model 8 considering that .35 Remington still exists and the other 3 cartridges can be made from its brass.

Nice. Still can handle it.

A rifle that combined the best features of both would be great.

COWBOY AK
O
W
B
O
Y
A
K

Attached: remington-model-81-police-gun.jpg (1500x449, 238K)

>none of these are .22
Why

Which one is favored by law enforcement the most?

Not enough stopping power for .22

There was a pre-1907 in .22lr

That seems hold a quite of punch. Going to the lighter recoil aka Winchester then.

Both of them are used to gun down Bonnie and Clyde

Based

Any close example?

Remington.....
Price ammo for any of the calibers the Winchester was chambered in and you'll see why

>.351 SL
Why is it rare though?

Winchester in Hyman Lehman configuration.

I had a 1907. Huge pain in the ass to disassemble.

Because it's dead. Not niche, or rare, but dead. Question is why wasn't the M1 carbine a .351

>That seems hold a quite of punch. Going to the lighter recoil aka Winchester then.

Pussy. Half starved soldiers and even children shot 8mm mausers during ww2

.

Remington

just the long mag?
you are like little baby
watch this
T O M M Y G R I P

Attached: remington model 8.jpg (1200x412, 37K)

81 Woodmaster is better

>Tommygrip
It's Hyman Lehman grip

Which one is expensive?

...

US army demanded it be .30

Carbine huh

Which one is the base of M1 Garand?